Desktop OSs Reviews
13,657 Reviews

Windows Vista: the new interface

From £99 to £323 depending on version

Manufacturer: Microsoft

Our Rating: We rate this 4 out of 5 User Rating: Our users rate this 2 out of 10

The moment Windows Vista starts, some of its biggest changes are in plain view: the new interface is distinctive and eye-catching. Colours are subtler and the overall look is less cartoonish than Windows XP's.

This article appears as part of our comprehensive guide to Windows Vista in the March 07 issue of PC Advisor, available now in all good newsagents. Click here to visit our dedicated Windows Vista forum.

Vista looks very Mac-like, but then Microsoft has always borrowed from the best. Key to a lot of what's new in Vista is the much-anticipated opaque and sometimes 3D Aero interface – but to use it, you'll need adequate hardware and one of the pricier versions of the OS.

Within Aero, windows maximise and minimise with a visual swoosh. The Alt, Tab command for switching between open windows now invokes Windows Flip, which displays thumbnails of open windows. Flip 3D ups the ante, stacking windows so that you can flip through them like playing cards.

Flip is an upgraded version of the Alt, Tab Task Switcher from earlier versions of Windows. The key combination gives you a palette of all open programs – you hold down the Alt key and cycle through those programs with the Tab key. The one that’s selected when you let go of the Alt key will then open up front and centre on your screen. What's different is that instead of names of programs with static icons, Flip uses the live thumbnails for those programs, which makes it a good deal easier to find what you want.

Two other notable new elements are the Sidebar and Live Thumbnails. Hover your mouse over a minimised window on the taskbar and a thumbnail pops up with its contents, plus the program and document name or website. We’re particularly fond of the Sidebar gadgets. These interactive applets display information, such as RSS feeds, stock tickers, clocks and weather reports. Vista comes with a dozen or so, and there are many more online.

While similar to Google Desktop Gadgets or Yahoo Widgets, they're actually more like the Mac’s Widgets in that they're built directly into the operating system and so may use its underlying architecture. For example, one gadget displays RSS newsfeeds you’ve subscribed to using Internet Explorer 7.0's RSS Reader.

The Start menu is more compact and useful than XP's, while the Control Panel is more logically organised. It has several new Centers, such as the Network and Sharing Center and the Sync Center. The latter handles functions of ActiveSync desktop software you previously had to install for Windows Mobile devices.

But for some odd reason several differently named links bring you to the exact same location. For example, in Control Panel, Network and Internet, if you click 'Network and Sharing Center' or 'View network status and tasks' or 'Set up file sharing', each of these choices will take you to… the Network and Sharing Center.

This can make using Control Panel feel like getting directions from a dotty old aunt.

Windows Vista Expert Verdict »

Price comparison powered by Reevoo

£156
Post Review

Reviewed by Robo1270 on Friday 08 May 2009

1 star rating

Duration of ownership: 2 years

Strengths:
It's very pretty.

Weaknesses:
It's too pretty and slows down system.

Overall Evaluation:
Vista's Aero Interface is pretty, but slow if you having a old PC.

Reviewed by trc on Friday 12 October 2007

2 star rating

Duration of ownership: 6 days

Strengths:
Looks pretty, Clean installs very quickly.

Weaknesses:
No 64 bit modem drivers, cannot get online. AVG says 64 bit Vista ready - Vista says no. Dual-core SATA no faster than 6-year-old hardware under XP. Only sleeps for seconds before waking.

Overall Evaluation:
I'd like to keep it, but without multimedia support for ATi AIW, Virus checking, web connection, then it's back in the box for however long it takes to get to the point where it works properly not just look pretty. I'll have to utilise the massively greater power of my new build system, by transferring the old XP license across and have everything work again.

Reviewed by HenryVII on Friday 21 September 2007

2 star rating

Duration of ownership: 4 days

Strengths:
Colourful.

Weaknesses:
If you change your mind after a restore/copy and want to delete of move files, life can get extremely frustrating. Vista is obsessed with security.

Overall Evaluation:
Nice if you are starting from scratch, dreadful if you need to man-handle lots of files from an XP backup following the collapse of the XP PC. I wish I'd stuck to XP for my new machine. So far I can't see any real advantage.

Reviewed by grayfox511 on Monday 20 August 2007

2 star rating

Duration of ownership: 60 days

Strengths:
It is pretty

Weaknesses:
Will not run some software. Lack of vista compliant hardware and drivers.

Overall Evaluation:

800MHz processor
512MB system memory
DirectX 9.0-compatible graphics processor
  • Ease of Use: We give this item 9 of 10 for ease of use
  • Features: We give this item 9 of 10 for features
  • Value for Money: We give this item 7 of 10 for value for money
  • Overall: We give this item 8 of 10 overall

Windows' new interface is distinctive and eye-catching. Colours are subtler and the overall look is less cartoonish than Windows XP's. Some may say this is mere eye candy that won’t affect your real productivity. Maybe so. But it makes life at the keyboard fun again. And for our money, that's right up there with productivity as a selling point.

Price comparison powered by Reevoo

£156
  • Flip Video Mino review

    Flip Video Mino

    In case you didn't have enough reasons to worry about videos of your escapades showing up online, Flip Video has made video posting easier than ever.

  • Microsoft Windows Vista review

    Microsoft Windows Vista

    Windows Vista finally launches on 30 January – and we've got a comprehensive review to help you decide whether to upgrade.

  • Microsoft Windows 8 review

    Microsoft Windows 8

    Windows 8 represents the biggest change to Microsoft’s operating system since the launch of Windows 95. Here’s our Windows 8 review. It’s the only Windows 8 review you are going to need.

  • Windows Vista: bundled applications

    Simply opening and closing windows and tweaking your system gets dull after a while. Windows Vista includes far more built-in applications than Windows XP while stalwarts such as Notepad, WordPad and Paint are pretty much unchanged. The following are the high (and low) points of the most notable new apps.

  • Microsoft Windows 7 review

    Microsoft Windows 7

    With its Windows 7 OS, Microsoft gets the basics right. It just works, and after Windows Vista that may be enough to make it a winner. Read PC Advisor's in-depth expert review to find out more.

Send to a friend

Email this article to a friend or colleague:


PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the recipient know who sent the story. Both your name and the recipient's name and address will not be used for any other purpose.