We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
Reference and education software Reviews
15,670 Reviews

Encyclopedia face-off: Britannica vs Encarta

£40 inc VAT

Manufacturer: Microsoft

Our Rating: We rate this 3.5 out of 5

We tested Encyclopædia Britannica 2007 Ultimate Reference Suite and Encarta Reference Library 2007 to find the best DVD-based encyclopedia.

The following review appears in the December 06 issue of PC Advisor, available now in all good newsagents. The scores, system requirements and screenshot to the right are for Encyclopædia Britannica 2007 Ultimate Reference Suite; to see details of Encarta Reference Library 2007, kindly click here.

The nights are drawing in, the clocks are going back, students have long since returned to school and university. It's the time of year when encyclopedia makers release updates of their reference DVDs.

In this age of the internet you might wonder if it's worth shelling out for a DVD-based encyclopedia, so we've taken a look at the main free online alternative, Wikipedia (see below). But it's not just about money – and there are reasons why Encarta and Britannica are worth a look.

For starters, they make finding information simple, which will appeal to those who aren't confident searching the internet. They're better at zeroing in on research, so you'll waste less time trawling through irrelevant information. And they are quick in use. If you are still using a dialup connection, they'll beat the internet hands down. Finally, they provide age-appropriate, fact-checked information, which isn't something that can be said for the internet.

School supplies

Encarta incorporates a version of the program aimed at children, and designed to feature content suitable for younger users. Britannica covers even more ground: besides the standard reference product, it features two separate versions for primary- and secondary-school children respectively.

But Britannica's products are biased too much towards the US market. When you click on the atlas you can see only the US and Canada in detail – and when you explore the articles they focus on American history and famous figures.

In contrast, Encarta has been fully rewritten for the UK market and provides links to quintessentially British topics, such as cricket, rugby and football. The student version teaches about British history and political systems. And Encarta provides links to articles from The Times, rather than US publications.

Another problem we encountered with Britannica was that it was time-consuming to install. Unlike Encarta, there is no option to run the software from the disc. The installation process took us well over half an hour. And it takes up 2GB of space, as opposed to the 850MB Encarta requires. It's quite slow in displaying search results – and unless you do a full install, you still have to put in the disc to view multimedia content.

You might expect Britannica to run slower than Encarta, since it holds 75,000 articles as opposed to 42,000. However, this doesn't translate into more comprehensive or up-to-date results. When we entered 'London', Britannica returned bags of very old information, while Encarta included images of the 7 July bombings – wholly unmentioned by Britannica.

The interfaces of both products are easy to use, with clear links to find features and information. But we found Encarta's interface clearer, with the results pages proving simpler to navigate.

Research tools

There are some features in Britannica that make research more interesting. These include the Brainstormer – which provides links to relevant topics relating to your search – and Timelines, which allows you to view events relating to specific areas, such as art, daily life and childhood, all in chronological order. Unsurprisingly, this feature suffers from a US bias.

Encarta offers an interactive game called Mindmaze, which encourages you to explore all the content with quizzes and links to articles. It includes a timeline feature, though this isn't as detailed as Britannica's, consisting of a straightforward historical timeline with links to more information about all the main events. But we did like the quotations search and the Map Treks feature found in Encarta, which shows you different views of regions of the world: for example, a map of city lights across the globe.

Although the internet constitutes the main rival to products such as this, both encyclopedias turn the tables and use the web to their advantage, adding to the content on offer. Both include one year's online updates to ensure that the information provided is up to date. Encarta adds a toolbar to Explorer, so that every time you request a search you can automatically access any relevant information held in Encarta. And it provides useful web links with each search. Britannica allows you to link to an online search from within a topic to find extra information.

Each product includes extra language-related reference products. Encarta has a UK English dictionary and thesaurus, plus dictionaries from French, Italian, Spanish and German to English (and vice versa). Britannica includes Merriam-Webster's Dictionary and Thesaurus but – you guessed it – it's written in US English.

Wikipedia: a rapidly growing internet rival to DVD-based encyclopedias

While disc-based encyclopedias still have their place, that place is rapidly being eroded by online reference sites. The most famous of these is Wikipedia. Wikipedia is free, but it has several other advantages, too.

The site is constantly updated, which means it's particularly strong on current affairs and popular culture. Wikipedia can give you an entire episode guide to Lost, while the DVDs don't even mention it.

Because Wikipedia is created and updated by its users, it's a great resource for esoteric information, such as profiles of local celebrities or information on regional delicacies. With more than five million entries, there isn't much that you can't find out about on Wikipedia.

However, because content comes from the community, it may not be entirely accurate. And since anyone with an internet connection can update entries, some pages are prone to vandalism. However, US magazine Nature recently compared Wikipedia's scientific content with that of Britannica and found the accuracy and depth of information to be comparable.

Another benefit of Wikipedia over disc-based products is that it won't eat up your system resources, while containing much more information. Most entries have a list of websites to provide more information. Overall, Wikipedia wins – mainly because it's free and provides an enormous amount of content. But for children or those less confident on the internet, a disc-based product is easier to use and promises accuracy.

Encarta Reference Library 2007 Expert Verdict »
MICROSOFT ENCARTA RF 07 Scores 9.0 out of 10 based on 5 reviews
Encarta Reference Library 2007: 600MHz Pentium processor
Microsoft Windows XP SP2
256MB RAM
850MB hard disk space
DVD-ROM drive
  • Ease of Use: We give this item 7 of 10 for ease of use
  • Features: We give this item 7 of 10 for features
  • Value for Money: We give this item 6 of 10 for value for money
  • Overall: We give this item 7 of 10 overall

Overall, we were disappointed by Britannica. Despite boasting such a huge range of articles, it wasn't very useful to a British audience. It's discourteous to expect UK customers to pay for a product that is clearly aimed at a US audience and, as such, is of limited use to anyone else. This problem is compounded by a poorer use of the internet, a more cluttered interface and, most unforgivably, a higher price. There are some features that we did like, including the division of content into three categories for different age groups, the impressive Timelines and the Brainstormer feature, but these simply weren't enough to make up for Britannica's shortcomings. Encarta, on the other hand, offers better value, ease of use, an attractive, clean layout and content that has been localised for the UK market. It's a great reference tool – particularly for children – and uses the internet as a resource intelligently. It wins our recommendation hands down.

There are currently no price comparisons for this product.
  • Encyclopedia face-off: Encarta vs Britannica

    Encyclopedia face-off: Encarta vs Britannica

    We tested Encyclopædia Britannica 2007 Ultimate Reference Suite and Encarta Reference Library 2007 to find the best DVD-based encyclopedia.

  • Wikipedia review

    Wikipedia

    This user-generated online encyclopedia has 16 million articles, providing a superb primer on almost any subject. Most pages can be edited by anyone, which gives Wikipedia unmatched editorial resources, but makes it vulnerable to vandalism.

  • Encyclopaedia Britannica Ultimate Reference Suite 2008

    Encyclopaedia Britannica Ultimate Reference Suite 2008

    In this age of the internet, where all the information and misinformation you could ever wish for is just a Google search away, it's easy to question the value of such reference software programs as Encyclopaedia Britannica Ultimate Reference Suite 2008.

  • Encyclopaedia Britannica Ultimate Edition review

    Encyclopaedia Britannica Ultimate Edition

    Is there a place for an electronic, DVD-based version of Encyclopaedia Britannica in the post-Wikipedia world? We tested Encyclopaedia Britannica 2009 Ultimate Edition to find out.

  • Encyclopædia Britannica 2006 DVD

    Encyclopædia Britannica 2006 DVD

    If knowledge is power, get ready to be crowned King Brainbox - provided you've got the time to read the 180,000 articles contained in this little collection.


IDG UK Sites

Amazon Kindle Voyage release date, price and specs UK: a high-end eReader with Amazon’s best-ever...

IDG UK Sites

Why local multiplayer gaming is rapidly vanishing: we look at the demise of split-screen and LAN...

IDG UK Sites

How to successfully bridge the gap between clients and creatives

IDG UK Sites

How to update your iPhone or iPad to iOS 8: including how to install iOS 8 if you don't have room