We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
Office software Reviews
15,670 Reviews

Serenity Software Editor review

$55 (around £35)

Manufacturer: Serenity Software

Our Rating: We rate this 3.5 out of 5

Serenity Software Editor finds grammar and word usage mistakes that your word processor may miss. Check our Serenity Software Editor review for mistakes!

As a writer and an editor, I have a love-hate relationship with Serenity Software Editor (various pricing; ten-day free trial). This copyediting and proofreading application not only identifies common grammatical errors, but also thoroughly analyzes your writing for other weaknesses. I love that it focuses on good, solid writing. I just hate the fact that so many folks - myself included - actually need it. See all: Software Downloads.

Editor is available in two versions. The $55 (you're always charged in US$) Standard version analyzes documents from many word processors (including Microsoft Word), as well as many HTML, RTF, and all plain-text documents, but presents its output in a plain text file. If you're going to use Editor to analyze Microsoft Word documents, I highly suggest springing for the $75 Editor for Word, which includes the same features as the Standard version, but also features a Word add-in that allows you to see Editor's output within Microsoft Word itself.

Serenity Software suggests reading its help documents, which include a short Getting Started doc and a longer one, called "Using Editor Efficiently," before you begin using Editor. And doing so is necessary: The program itself is not entirely intuitive. To begin using either version, you close your document or file, and then open Editor. You then click the "Draft" button from the basic-looking but perfectly serviceable menu, and import your document into Editor. The company recommends doing this every time you use Editor.

Once your file has been imported, you're brought back to Editor's main menu, where you click "Usage." Here, you can decide which of Editor's tools you'd like to use: All, Fix, Spell 1, Spell 2, Tighten, Polish, and Consider. While the tools (called "Dictionaries") run quickly, you do spend a lot of time clicking buttons and viewing various menus; it would be easier to use Editor if these steps were combined in a more user-friendly fashion.

After these tools have run, you're brought back to the main menu again. Now it's time to view the results of Editor's analysis, and this is where the Standard version and Editor for Word part ways. In the Standard version, you're limited to viewing your work in a text document, where all the sentences are numbered, and are presented with a second text document that lists your "errors" according to sentence number. Using the Word add-in, you can view these errors (some of which may be mere suggestions) as pop-ups as you move through the document. The Word add-in provides a much more streamlined, user-friendly approach.

The results that you see are the same in both versions. Editor does not check basic spelling--it suggests you run your word processor's spellchecker before using it--but does check for improper use of words, misused hyphens, improperly used phrases, wordiness, missing or erroneous punctuation, and more. Not all of its suggestions are useful for every style of writing, and the folks at Editor stress that you should not act upon all of its suggestions. Instead, they suggest that you consider the changes that it suggests, and decide for yourself if they will help your writing. To that end, no changes are applied automatically: You must manually make any edits yourself.

I have to admit that I was pleasantly surprised at how well Editor analyzed my writing--once I got over the shock of seeing just how many errors it pointed out. I quickly realized that I could ignore many of its suggestions, and just how easy Editor makes it to identify those that actually do need attention. The program uses language like "grammatical error" to label errors that it definitely identifies, while in other cases it uses terms like "possible poor usage" or "possible redundant expression," to highlight situations where you might want to consider making a change.

Serenity Software Editor Expert Verdict »

Microsoft Windows 7, Microsoft Windows Vista, Microsoft Windows XP
  • Overall: We give this item 7 of 10 overall

Although I wish we lived in a world without a need for Programs like Editor, I have to admit - however grudgingly - that we don't. There are no perfect writers, but we all can get a little bit better with Editor.

  • VanWrite Sentence Aerobics review

    VanWrite Sentence Aerobics

    Designed as a Word add-in, VanWrite's Sentence Aerobics is an online service that tries to help you write clearer, better business documents. Read our Sentence Aerobics review.

  • Microsoft Office 2010 review

    Microsoft Office 2010

    Has Microsoft got it right this time? PC Advisor tests and rates Microsoft Office 2010, and explains whether you should upgrade. Updated, May 20 2010.

  • WordQ + SpeakQ review

    WordQ + SpeakQ

    Frustrated writers, particularly students from elementary school through college, will appreciate WordQ + SpeakQ, a software duo for writers with learning disabilities or attention disorders.

  • Free Editor review - open and edit any document for free

    Free Editor - open and edit any document for free

    Free Editor is free software that lets you open and edit over 70 different file types for free. Here's our Free Editor review.

  • Google Docs & Spreadsheets

    For those seeking an alternative to Office, OpenOffice is comprehensive. But Google offers a very different approach.

IDG UK Sites

How to get Microsoft Edge (Project Spartan) browser in Windows 10: Download with Windows Insider...

IDG UK Sites

In defence of BlackBerrys

IDG UK Sites

Autonomous Desk is a voice-controlled sit/stand desk

IDG UK Sites

Apple 13in MacBook Pro review (2.7GHz, 256GB, Retina display, Early 2015, £1,199): middle 13in...