We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
Reference and education software Reviews
15,670 Reviews

Goodreads review


Manufacturer: Goodreads

Our Rating: We rate this 3.5 out of 5

Goodreads is an independent online community for book lovers, with a powerful, Netflix-like recommendation engine helping you find new and interesting books to read.

Goodreads is similar to the Amazon-owned Shelfari community in that it is all about books, but it offers a very different take on the subject - so much so, that you might want to keep accounts on both websites. Membership is required, but free.

To use the Goodreads website, you must first select your favourite genres from a long list, which oddly enough includes "eBooks", even though that is not a genre. Then, to prime the site's recommendation engine, you are asked to rate 20 books, with a selection shown from each genre you picked. It also asks your permission to search for your friends in social networks, but that is optional. See all: PC Advisor software downloads

When you rate a book favorably at Goodreads, the site pops open a short list of books similar to it. When I liked Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, Goodreads suggested The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay, a book that I indeed want to read. Other recommendations felt similarly accurate.

Much like in Netflix, you can mark a book as "want to read," rate it (only if you already read it), or click "Not interested," which is a tiny link under the rating stars. Rating a book or adding it to your wishlist is a simple, one-click affair. This is very different from Shelfari, where adding a book to your collection opens a multi-step wizard that can take a couple of minutes to step through.

Once you've rated 20 books, you can access your personalized Goodreads recommendation list. The list shows five books from each of your genres, with a link for more. When you hover over a recommendation, Goodreads shows you why it was picked, as well as its publication date, a synopsis, a star rating, and how many people rated the book (a number that's usually in the thousands, indicative of an active community).

Like Shelfari, Goodreads uses a "shelves" metaphor, but here it's just a fancy name for a list or a grid of cover thumbnails. Another point of similarity is that Goodreads can search for fellow Goodreads users amongst you contacts on Twitter, Facebook, Gmail and more, but the site is very useful even with no social context.

Goodreads' individual book listings are a far cry from Shelfari's encyclopedic, metadata-rich listings. Details such as characters and locations are hidden under a tiny "more details" link, which is also used to reveal the complete synopsis. There are quotes, sorted by how many people liked them, but with no attribution to the character in the book that said them.

Goodreads sets reader reviews front and center. Each book listing is basically a collection of reviews, with an Amazon-like breakdown showing how many reviewers gave the book each star rating, so you can see what its average rating is composed of. You can "like" a review, but you can't "dislike" it or mark it "not helpful." You can also comment on a review, much like in Amazon.

You can access a "Stats" view for each book, which is a chart showing how many people added the book to their shelves over time, rated it, reviewed it, and marked it as "to read". This makes for an interesting gauge of a book's popularity and life cycle, but data starts on August 2011, so the time span is a bit too short for making any conclusions.

There's also "Get a copy" button that lets you search for the book on Amazon, B&N, Kobo, Half.com, and several other likely sources. Book Depository, a store offering free international shipping on every order, is sadly missing. There is also a price comparison engine that didn't work for me (it came up blank). Next to it is a button leading to WorldCat, a website that lets you check if a local library happens to have this title in stock.

Authors have their own pages, and some authors even maintain blogs on the site. Others, such as Terry Pratchett, blog elsewhere, and Goodreads pulls in the feeds from their site and displays their recent blog posts on the author page. Clicking the subject line of a post leads to a scraped copy of the post, which is sometimes a bit broken (like this post from Pratchett, which shows anchor tags along the bottom). Worse still, Goodreads readers can comment right on that page, perhaps thinking that their comment will reach the author. The right thing to do would be to link from the RSS feed directly to the blog, so users can comment there - much like Google Reader does.

Goodreads Expert Verdict »

Linux, Macintosh OS X, Microsoft Windows 7, Microsoft Windows Vista
Web browser, Internet connection
  • Overall: We give this item 7 of 10 overall

Scraping shenanigans aside, Goodreads offers a strong and compelling recommendation engine, making it a better source for future reading material than Shelfari. So for learning more about a book, go with Shelfari. To find books to read, I recommend Goodreads.

  • Kindle for PC review (2012)

    Kindle for PC (2012)

    Kindle for PC is a very capable, full-featured and free e-book reader with great extras.

  • The Dream Machine review

    The Dream Machine

    Rumours of the death of the point-and-click adventure have been greatly exaggerated, and The Dream Machine is here to prove it.

  • Audio Lunchbox review

    Audio Lunchbox

    Audio Lunchbox is an easy-to-explore music download site that offers a vast selection of indie-label albums from a variety of genres.

  • Google Movies app review

    Google Movies app

    With Google Play, the Android entertainment options have taken a large step forward. The slick interface and good choice of titles, plus a sensible pricing structure ensure Android users will be won over by the natively available video on demand option.

  • Philips SA9345 digital audio and video player

    Philips SA9345 digital audio and video player

    The Philips SA9345 is a great-looking digital audio and video player that’s easy to navigate and boasts an FM tuner, which is always a plus.

IDG UK Sites

Windows 10 release date, price, features UK: Staggered release with PCs coming first this summer -...

IDG UK Sites

In defence of BlackBerrys

IDG UK Sites

Why we should reserve judgement on Apple ditching Helvetica in OS X/iOS for the Apple Watch's San...

IDG UK Sites

MacBook Pro 15in preview: better battery life, faster storage and a new discrete graphics chip may...