We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
Graphic design & publishing software Reviews
15,670 Reviews

RealWorld Icon Editor review

$47 (around £28)

Manufacturer: RealWorld Graphics

Our Rating: We rate this 4 out of 5

RealWorld Icon Editor is really four programs - a basic photo editor, a 3D modeler, a picture creator, and a tool that makes static icons from the images you create.

RealWorld Icon Editor is really four programs - a basic photo editor, a 3D modeler, a picture creator, and a tool that makes static icons from the images you create.

The icon-creating tool automatically generates a variety of sizes from 16 pixels square to 256 pixels square; a choice of smooth edges, 256 colours, or 16 colours; and allows you to save a variety of formats optimizing your image as an icon, avatar, or favicon for either PC or Mac.

Turning a photo into an image suitable for making into an icon will be familiar to anyone who's used a photo editor. Open any .jpg, .tif, .psd, .gif, .png, or .bmp file in RealWorld Icon Editor and crop, resize, touch-up, and paint over the image using paint brush, eraser, and fill tools. You can also add stock images, backgrounds, and textures from an included library of royalty-free graphics and dingbats, or just add text and draw freehand.

Brilliantly, Icon Editor will save the adapted image as a .jpg, .bmp, or .png at your original resolution, however large, meaning that you don't need a separate graphic design program to match your icons, avatars, favicons, and even logos and other art in your Web and print branding. Once you have your basic design saved in its native format, one button click will send it to the next step: transforming it into multiple icons, avatars, or favicons.

The 3D design tools are lodged firmly at the steeper end of the learning curve. RealWorld Icon Editor allows you to create simple 3D objects made from preformed geometric shapes - arrow, box, cone, cylinder, prism, pyramid, sphere, slope, tank, tetrahedron, or torus - or text, to which you can add drop shadows, tweak, stretch, rotate, and change the light source. In addition, Icon Editor can take an existing 3D model and allow you to define and save snapshots with custom camera and lighting parameters.

If you're new to 3D design and modeling, this aspect of RealWorld Icon Editor can be intimidating. But knowing the difference between, say, the extrusion surface and the surface of revolution doesn't matter all that much unless you are trying to create a very specific design. Getting your desired effect may come down to watching a video tutorial and then spinning, flipping, and stretching the object until it looks right.

You can continue to tweak your image after saving it as an avatar, icon, or favicon. Add a projected shadow or drop shadow, sharpen your image, even add text. In addition, RealWorld adds two utilities that make Icon Editor exceptional: the ability to independently tweak different sized icons starting from the same image, and a perpetual preview - essential for making sure your tiny favicon works just as well as your avatar or your original file, but still looks like it's uniquely yours.

Icon Editor doesn't make animated icons, which is a little disappointing, and its $47 pricetag is on the high side for a simple icon editor. Picture To Icon costs $40, and Icon Office $30. The costs are in US Dollars, even if you are paying from the UK.

However, considering Icon Editor's features that these other programs lack, including 3D modeling, high res-image editing, and photo editing tools, if you need a program to create cross-branded and various format icons and other images, this is the one to use.

Batch operation, the only feature in this release that is included exclusively in the $89 professional version of Icon Editor, can create icons from images; convert icons from windows to Mac format and vice versa; extract images from icons; create previews of icons; extract icons; and perform user-defined custom operations. If you need to batch process any of these, it's worth the upgrade.

See all: PC Advisor software downloads

See also: Group test: what's the best 3D design software?

RealWorld Icon Editor Expert Verdict »

Windows XP, Windows Vista, Windows 7
256MB RAM, 40MB free hard disk space
  • Overall: We give this item 8 of 10 overall

Regardless of your experience, RealWorld Icon Editor can help you create very professional-looking graphics with a bit of effort and minimal cost.

  • Logitech QuickCam Fusion

    Logitech QuickCam Fusion

    It doesn't matter how hard you try; when you sit down in front of a webcam you end up looking like you’ve been dragged through a hedge 50 or 60 times on a very hot day. Well, Logitech is doing its best to remedy this situation with the QuickCam Fusion.

  • Bitstrips review: Create your own Facebook comic strip and avatar

    Bitstrips: Create your own Facebook comic strip and avatar

    What better way to spend a morning hanging around a deserted train station in the aftermath of St. Jude than to create hilarious comics starring yourself and your Facebook friends. This is the service offered by free Android and iOS app Bitstrips, and by now you'll almost certainly have witnessed its popularity through the cartoon adventures plastered all over your Facebook news feed.

  • Xara Photo & Graphic Designer 6 review

    Xara Photo & Graphic Designer 6

    Xara Photo & Graphic Designer 6 is a graphic design alternative to Photoshop that specialises in doing one thing really well: desktop publishing. Updated, 9 June 2011

  • Xara Xtreme Pro

    Xara Xtreme Pro

    While Xara Xtreme may appear to be a vector-based application, it can easily be turned towards creating content for the web and exporting simple Flash or GIF animations.

  • HP EliteBook 2740p review

    HP EliteBook 2740p

    The HP EliteBook 2740p adds a twist to the typical design of ultraportable laptops. But is this hybrid ultraportable/touchscreen tablet PC a good investment? Read our HP EliteBook 2740p review to find out


IDG UK Sites

iPad mini 3 vs iPad mini 2 comparison: New iPad mini 3 isn't worth £80 more

IDG UK Sites

Why you shouldn't buy the iPad mini 3: No wonder Apple gave it 10 seconds of stage time

IDG UK Sites

Halloween Photoshop tutorials: 13 masterclasses for horrifying art, designs and type

IDG UK Sites

Should I upgrade from Mavericks to OS X 10.10 Yosemite? What you need to know before updating to...