We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
Software Reviews
15,670 Reviews

Google Talk Beta

N/A

Manufacturer: Google

Our Rating: We rate this 4 out of 5

Gloriously clutter-free, Google Talk's beta gives you text and voice messaging, smooth integration with Gmail, rudimentary customisation options… and that's about it. It's yet another potentially exciting service from the search giant that you can use in its beta form.

Gloriously clutter-free, Google Talk's beta gives you text and voice messaging, smooth integration with Gmail, rudimentary customisation options… and that's about it. To try Google Talk you need an account with Gmail – or Google Mail as we are now supposed to refer to the webmail service in the UK. It's yet another potentially exciting service from the search giant that you can use in its beta form.

If you have an account, you can get rolling by inviting Gmail contacts of your choosing to download the free Google Talk app; these contacts are automatically moved into the program. Installing the IM (instant-messaging) application is quick and painless, and it starts up in just a few seconds.

The first thing that struck us about Google Talk was its simplicity – a rare thing in the realm of IM applications. If you're used to working with a program that is laden with features and customisation options, you'll find Google Talk startlingly austere. It's truly bare-boned, with limited customisation settings.

Warm and clean

Once we had Google Talk up and running, we actually warmed to the squeaky-clean environment. It's advert and pop-up free, includes lots of white space and contains no annoying clusters of icons to distract you from your messaging business. In fact, going from the likes of Yahoo Messenger to Google Talk is a bit like going from a noisy consumer electronics superstore to a quiet boutique up a side street.

We also liked being able to detach the messaging window from the contacts list and move both around. If you re-attach them by placing the messaging pane below the contacts window, the former automatically resizes itself to fit the latter's vertical profile.

If you leave Google Talk's Notifications settings at their default values, you'll receive an alert every time an email drops into your Gmail account. A small window pops up briefly, identifying the sender's name and the subject line. That's handy if you want to keep an eye out for something in particular. But if you get dozens of emails every hour you may want to turn off those signals.

In our voice chat tests, call quality sounded impressive – initially. Despite a faint hum in the background, our editor's voice and mine sounded crisp, and our sentences stayed intact. But further into the conversation things went downhill: it sounded as though we were both talking on mobile phones in a car wash. The slushing sound became so distracting that we simply hung up.

You might consider Google Talk somewhat exclusive, since you need to be part of the Gmail club to get it. But it's not a closed circuit; the Google Talk network is compatible with the XMPP (Extensible Messaging and Presence Protocol), which lets you send IMs to other XMPP-compliant programs, such as Gaim, Jabber and iChat. Your buddies will need to have Gmail and configure their IM program to work accordingly.

What's missing?

Perhaps the most glaring omission – given that this comes from Google, whose mission is 'to organise the world's information' – is the fact that the text IM messages are not logged, stored or indexed. So the only IM service that Google's desktop search can't index is Google's own. Not everyone searches their logs, but those of us that do will avoid Google Talk for instant messaging until this is put right.

The number of options is very small compared with open-source clients such as Gaim, or with Yahoo, Skype and AIM (or even MSN Messenger). It doesn't do video, it doesn't share images, it doesn't do voicemail. It doesn't offer encryption. It only does voice if you use the Google Talk client, which runs only on Windows – so there is no mobile Google Talk at present. That said, all is not lost on the video side. Google Talkers yearning for this feature can try a plug-in called Festoon by Santa Cruz Networks.

Google Talk Beta Expert Verdict »

300MHz Pentium processor or equivalent
Windows 2000/XP
64MB RAM
900KB hard disk space
internet connection
  • Ease of Use: We give this item 9 of 10 for ease of use
  • Features: We give this item 4 of 10 for features
  • Value for Money: We give this item 10 of 10 for value for money
  • Overall: We give this item 8 of 10 overall

If you rely on Gmail, and have built up a large address book, Google Talk lets you integrate text and voice messaging very easily. But if you want much more than that, look elsewhere. However, Google has the knack of improving beta software and coming up with winners, so watch this space.

  • Google Voice review

    Google Voice

    Chances are you've heard or read about Google's phone management system Google Voice, but you're not really sure what it does. Google Voice is a free web-based application that lets you control all your various phone numbers - work, home, mobile, you name it - from a single, central phone number. UPDATED: 29 June 2009.

  • Aliph Jawbone Icon review

    Aliph Jawbone Icon

    Aliph's new Jawbone Icon Bluetooth headset aims to combine good looks and a customisable, voice-driven interface.

  • Linspire Five-0 Beta

    You might not have heard of Linspire Linux before; that's because this is the first version that has gone under this name. After a legal wrangle with Microsoft, Lindows had to change its name to Linspire - which serves to underline both the imbalance of power and Microsoft's strong-arm tactics in the operating system market these days.

  • Xobni Smartr Inbox for Gmail review

    Xobni Smartr Inbox for Gmail

    Smartr Inbox for Gmail by Xobni makes Gmail much more than just an excellent email tool: It helps turn it into a central hub for all of your electronic communications, including social networking via Facebook, LinkedIn, and Twitter.

  • Miranda IM 0.9 review

    Miranda IM 0.9

    Merge multiple instant messengers into a single, open-source app with the latest version of Miranda IM.


IDG UK Sites

Best Christmas 2014 UK tech deals, Boxing Day 2014 UK tech deals & January sales 2015 UK tech...

IDG UK Sites

LED vs Halogen: Why now could be the right time to invest in LED bulbs

IDG UK Sites

Christmas' best ads: See great festive spots studios have created to promote themselves and clients

IDG UK Sites

Why Apple shouldn't be blamed for exploitation in China and Indonesia