We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
NAS (network storage) Reviews
15,522 Reviews PC Advisor Recommended

Western Digital My Book Live review

£154 inc VAT

Manufacturer: Western Digital

Our Rating: We rate this 4 out of 5

Western Digital's My Book series of consumer network-attached storage NAS drives has a new variant, the 2TB Western Digital My Book Live - REVISED 18 JAN 2011

Western Digital's My Book series of consumer network-attached storage boxes has a new variant, the 2TB Western Digital My Book Live NAS - REVISED 18 JAN 2011

Network attached storage – the NAS drive – may be a handy way to keep piles of data readily accessible at home. But it’s not always particularly quick – at least on most consumer drives anyway.

They may use the same hard disks as fast and fierce desktop PCs, but somewhere between the raw disk and your computer, data tends to get treacled.

Here’s some numbers: a 3.5in disk can easily dish the digits at 150MBps or more. When we measure the datarate at our PC, the average consumer NAS drive deals at 30Mbps or less. Often, much less. So our ears pricked up when Western Digital announced its new My Book Live with 100MBps read performance.

The WD My Book Live is a slimmed down volume compared to the company’s prior consumer NAS offerings, the My Book World Edition, and its bookish sequel, the My Book World Edition II.

The latter was after all just two internal hard disks under one cover. The speed-bragging WD My Book Live, meanwhile, remains a few millimetres thinner and shorter than even the first edition. It’s a simplified piece of hardware, for sure. There’s no USB port to add more storage or printers, nor even a power switch on the back any more.

Inside the WD My Book Live is a single 3.5in WD Caviar Green hard disk, either 1TB or 2TB capacity – a quiet, low-power drive optimised for home use and domestically innocuous compared to the speed demons that tend to get fitted to power PCs and servers.

It’s not silent, but it’s one of the quietest 3.5in disks you can buy right now. And the WD My Book Live is fanless, relying on convection cooling with its array of dot-and-dash perforations around the case.

Western Digital has spruced up the interface a little compared to its literary friends, with a dark but colourful webpage interface to help set up and manage the drive.

But it’s a doddle to do so, with the Support link in the left-hand list of options reassuringly underscored by the strapline ‘Let us help you’.

Improvements we appreciate in the simple interface include a new option to set the energy-saver time out duration.

Like other Western Digital consumer NAS drives, the WD My Book Live will appear automatically as a network server to Windows and Mac computers, with an FTP server thrown in for good measure.

Linux is not so immediately well served; but most Linux users will be accomplished enough to know how to get connected through manual means.

There’s also the Java-based MioNet service, to let you copy off your files when you're outside the home network.

A most worthy application of a NAS drive is computer backups. To this end, WD provides instructions for Windows 7 users to use the Backup and Restore feature in the OS to send files to the WD My Book Live. And Mac users can take advantage of OS X’s built-in Time Machine app to do the same, straight to the NAS.

Performance

We tried some time trials to see just how quick the WD My Book Live could be. We didn’t quite get the speed promised – but we did find the WD My Book Live to be the fastest consumer-level NAS we’ve seen.

Curiously, our tests with an Apple MacBook Pro (4,1) couldn’t elicit any read speeds faster than 57MBps, and writes to the drive never beat 47MBps. We tried dabbling with jumbo frames on our gigabit connection, to no tangible benefit.

In Windows 7 we saw faster speed on an Acer TimelineX 4820TG, also direct-connected over gigabit ethernet. Here we could copy large video files much quicker, the WD My Book Live indicating average read speeds up to 78MBps and writes to the drive at 48MBps.

NEXT PAGE: the review from PC World US

SKIP: to the PC Advisor verdict

See also:

Group test: what's the best NAS drive?

Group test: what's the best portable hard drive?

Western Digital My Book Live Expert Verdict »
WD 2TB My Book Live Hard Drive Scores 8.0 out of 10 based on 60 reviews
2TB NAS drive
Western Digital Caviar Green 3.5in SATA disk
gigabit ethernet
ENERGY STAR qualified
iTunes server, UPnP media server
external DC power supply
50 x 139 x 167mm
1.09kg
3-year warranty
  • Build Quality: We give this item 8 of 10 for build quality
  • Features: We give this item 8 of 10 for features
  • Value for Money: We give this item 8 of 10 for value for money
  • Overall: We give this item 8 of 10 overall

The My Book Live is the speediest consumer-oriented NAS drive we’ve seen. More than just spec-chasing, this brings real benefits in its use, shortening the wait for big file transfers and backups. It even makes the drive feel more like a local drive on your desktop, in its essential responsiveness with small-file access. Just make sure you have a gigabit network to take advantage of all this extra pace.

Price comparison powered by Reevoo

£170
  • Western Digital My Book World Edition II (4TB) review

    Western Digital My Book World Edition II (4TB)

    If the 1TB storage capacity of the My Book World Edition network-attached storage (NAS) device simply isn't enough, Western Digital's two-bay My Book World Edition II might be suitable. The Western Digital My Book World Edition II has the same functions as its 1TB counterpart but offers 2TB or 4TB of storage capacity and supports RAID.

  • WD My Cloud review: 2TB of web-accessible storage is great

    WD My Cloud: 2TB of web-accessible storage is great

    The WD My Cloud is a hard drive that connects to the web via your home network. Here's our WD My Cloud review.

  • Western Digital My Book World Edition 1TB review

    Western Digital My Book World Edition 1TB

    The 1TB Western Digital My Book World Edition is a handsomely styled, well-ventilated single-drive network storage box - just don't call it NAS... UPDATED 14 APRIL

  • WD Red 3TB review

    WD Red 3TB

    The WD Red is a new range of hard disks optimised for consumer and small business NAS drives.

  • Western Digital My Passport Edge (500GB) review

    Western Digital My Passport Edge (500GB)

    The WD My Passport Edge adds good looks and better transportability to Western Digital's My Passport line of portable hard drives. It's fast, but tops out at 500GB instead of the 2TB available with the non-Edge My Passport. Here's our WD My Passport Edge review.


IDG UK Sites

7 coolest 3D-printed objects: Body parts, houses, camera lenses and even pizza

IDG UK Sites

iOS 8 review: Hands on with the iOS 8 beta

IDG UK Sites

Thinking robots: The philosophy of artificial intelligence and evolving technology

IDG UK Sites

Sharknado 2 VFX: how The Asylum created CG flying man-eating sharks