We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
iPods & MP3 players Reviews
15,670 Reviews

Creative Zen Vision

£300 inc VAT

Manufacturer: Creative

Our Rating: We rate this 2.5 out of 5

Creative was one of the first companies to back Microsoft's Portable Media Center standard, with its Zen PMC (see Nov 04 issue). Now it's back with a new addition to its portable media player lineup, although this time the firm has decided to turn its back on Microsoft and go it alone - the Zen Vision runs Creative's own software. While the capabilities are similar to that of PMC, this brings both advantages and disadvantages.

Creative was one of the first companies to back Microsoft's Portable Media Center standard, with its Zen PMC (see Nov 04 issue). Now it's back with a new addition to its portable media player lineup, although this time the firm has decided to turn its back on Microsoft and go it alone - the Zen Vision runs Creative's own software. While the capabilities are similar to that of PMC, this brings both advantages and disadvantages.

Pros

Firstly, since Microsoft specified some quite strict hardware specs for PMC devices, by using its own software Creative is free to specify any hardware it please for the Vision - the most notable difference being the screen, which has twice the resolution of the PMC at 640x480 pixels.

Creative has also added support for more video codecs. In addition to WMV (Windows Media Video), the Vision will happily gobble up AVI, Mpeg1, 2 and 4, MJpeg (motion Jpeg), Divx 4 and 5, and Xvid. As a result, the Zen Vision can play a lot more video content without the need for conversion to WMV, which is a time-consuming process.

Cons

The down side of parting company with Microsoft is that the player interface is far less intuitive to use, and a lot less pretty. The more technical user probably won't mind, but for the uninitiated it could be a hurdle. The Vision also lacks some of the PMC's visual niceties, such as displaying album artwork while audio is playing. Again, no great loss - but a shame, nonetheless.

And despite the noticeable hardware improvements, there are also some issues with the screen - see Screen Burn, below, for more details.

While the Vision can handle a fair few video formats, Creative has also included a utility to convert any content you have to 320x240 WMV. The application is simple enough to use - just tell it what video you want to convert and then leave it to get on with the job. It's a slow process, however, with an hour's worth of video taking roughly an hour to convert.

The Vision is also supported by Windows Media Player 10.0, so you can simply hook it up and set it to sync with your media collection if that's your desktop player of choice.

In addition to video, the Vision supports audio in MP3, WMA (including digital rights management protection) and WAV and photos in Jpeg. If you're still bored, there's a built-in FM radio, although reception isn't great, as it uses the headphone lead for an aerial.

In an interesting move, Creative has popped a CompactFlash slot on the side of the Vision, allowing you to copy photos and videos directly to the device. Unfortunately, we couldn't get this to work as the only CompactFlash card we had in the office gave an error complaining of an unsupported file system, despite working perfectly well on a PC.

As for battery life, there are promises of four and a half hours for video and 13 hours for audio, with an optional extended battery available offering about double that.

Screen burn

Despite the Vision's improved resolution, it's not the best screen in the world. For a start it's very reflective - watch a dark piece of video and you'll soon find yourself focusing on your reflection and not the onscreen action. It also has an incredibly poor viewing angle. Move it just slightly to the left or the right and it becomes hard to make out the picture. Using it to show photos to a group of friends would be a frustrating task, since only two at most would be able to view them, and even then only just.

It also seems strange to opt for a 4:3 aspect ratio screen when the majority of content created these days is in widescreen 16:9.

Zen Vision Expert Verdict »


Creative Zen Vision:M 30GB reviews verified by Reevoo

Creative Zen Vision:M 30GBScores 8.6 out of 10 based on 83 reviews
Portable media player
30GB hard drive
battery life: 4.5 hours of video, 13 hours of audio
video playback
audio playback
image display
MTP
Windows Media Player 10.0-compatible
124x74x20mm
  • Build Quality: We give this item 6 of 10 for build quality
  • Features: We give this item 9 of 10 for features
  • Value for Money: We give this item 7 of 10 for value for money
  • Overall: We give this item 5 of 10 overall

The Vision improves on the PMC in some areas, but is lacking in others. The ability to play more video formats without conversion is welcome, but the screen is a letdown, despite its increased resolution. At £300 it's cheaper than the PMC but still relatively expensive.

  • Samsung YH-999 PMC

    The arrival of the Samsung YH-999 PMC (portable media center) provides the first serious challenge to Creative's well-received Zen PMC. Many industry analysts question the need for portable players that combine music, video, recorded TV and pictures (see It works, but would you use it? below). And despite the YH-999's attractive looks, Samsung's implementation of Microsoft's PMC specifications is unlikely to convert such critics.

  • Creative Zen Vision W portable media player

    Creative Zen Vision W portable media player

    Creative's Zen Vision W succeeds its Vision portable media player, gaining a W denoting its widescreen aspect. The epic 4.3in screen is fantastic, displaying both photos and video beautifully and in vivid detail.

  • Creative Zen Vision:M

    Creative Zen Vision:M

    Creative isn't new to the portable media player market – the Vision:M represents its third model with video playback capabilities, while arch-rival Apple is still on its first with the fifth-generation iPod.

  • Creative Zen V Plus media player

    Creative Zen V Plus media player

    The Creative Zen V Plus is an iPod-nano killer with a difference: it might actually be better than Apple's media player. Read PC Advisor's review of the the Creative Zen V Plus to find out why.

  • Archos 704 WiFi portable media player

    Archos 704 WiFi portable media player

    You may think Apple is king of portable player innovation, but there’s a lot to be said for Archos, too. Back when Apple and Creative were coming up with chunky music and, later, music and video players, Archos was besting them both. Archos has long offered support for more formats, larger capacity players and often manages to undercut them on price, too.


IDG UK Sites

Best Christmas 2014 UK tech deals, Boxing Day 2014 UK tech deals & January sales 2015 UK tech...

IDG UK Sites

LED vs Halogen: Why now could be the right time to invest in LED bulbs

IDG UK Sites

Christmas' best ads: See great festive spots studios have created to promote themselves and clients

IDG UK Sites

Why Apple shouldn't be blamed for exploitation in China and Indonesia