We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
15,669 Reviews

BBC iPlayer Beta review


Manufacturer: BBC

Our Rating: We rate this 3.5 out of 5 User Rating: Our users rate this 1 out of 10

BBC iPlayer is the BBC's on-demand TV download software and service.

BBC iPlayer is the BBC's on-demand TV download software. UPDATE, 8 July 2008: read our BBC iPlayer review here.

It doesn't currently need a lot of imagination to guess how the online revolution is going to craft and shape the television of the future. And despite its slightly crusty image, the BBC has a good reputation when it comes to harnessing new technology.

BBC iPlayer then, is its attempt to show us how, in the near-future, viewers will be able to pick and choose the programmes they want to see whenever and (pretty much) wherever they want – just as long as they've got access to a broadband connection and a suitably equipped computer.

The reference to a 'suitably equipped computer' is a salient one. BBC iPlayer, you see, is currently a beta version. Which means that there are niggles and problems with the BBC iPlayer software - quite a few, as it turns out - and the BBC is still testing the reliability and speed of the downloads.

And as for the 'suitably equipped computer' for BBC iPlayer? Well, you're going to need Windows Media Player to be running at version 10.0 or later. Internet Explorer will need to be at least version 6.0. And, oh yes, your PC will have to be running Windows XP.

There's no Vista version of BBC iPlayer yet although, with the help of an easily found crack on the internet, you can actually get the service working perfectly well in Vista Home Premium. Which makes it all the more strange that the BBC has imposed the XP-only restriction.

Once you've got through the rigorous signing up procedure and installed the software, you then browse through the list of programmes on the BBC's iPlayer website. The list contains many of the choice cuts from the previous seven days, along with a bunch of more surprising choices. Most of the expected names (Eastenders, Doctor Who, Panorama, The Proms etc.) are there and, thanks to BBC Three's habit of showing countless repeats, you can find the odd 'historic' episode of Little Britain and other such programmes.

It's nice to see the net cast so wide (even Questions from the House of Lords is available), although there were some notable omissions (BBC2's much-hyped American show, Heroes, was nowhere to be found). In the future, the BBC will presumably be looking to put out classic shows from the recent and not-so-recent past. For the time being though, the BBC iPlayer options are reasonably in-depth.

If you see anything you like, click on the button and BBC iPlayer will start downloading to the Library. File transfer is carried out through the peer-to-peer system Kontiki. This can make the download times rather erratic. The estimates suggested that a one hour programme should take about 20 minutes to download. In our experience, it took almost three times as long - even a 30 minute programme needed over half an hour to transfer. In fairness, the service was experiencing technical difficulties at the time of testing, and some other users reported download times in keeping with the estimates. Others didn't however, so there's clearly no consistency on this for the time being.

Once downloaded, BBC iPlayer programmes expire within seven days once watched (if not watched then within 30 days or less - depending on the original transmission date). Image quality was quite good on a 1,680x1,050 display, although the video did lack the sharpness you'd expect from a standard television image. It would have been nice, too, had we been able to get far more information about the nature of the recording. What would have been the optimal resolution? Standard or High Definition? Widescreen?

BBC iPlayer Expert Verdict »

500MHz Intel Pentium or AMD Athlon
Windows XP
512MB RAM, 500MB hard disk space
Internet Explorer 6.0
Windows Media Player 10.0
broadband connection
  • Ease of Use: We give this item 7 of 10 for ease of use
  • Features: We give this item 8 of 10 for features
  • Overall: We give this item 7 of 10 overall

There are a lot of teething troubles for the BBC to sort out with BBC iPlayer. However, this is certainly an interesting and, potentially, very versatile piece of software. More programmes, more information, faster downloads and fewer restrictions, and BBC iPlayer could yet blossom into a very useful utility.

  • BBC iPlayer review

    BBC iPlayer

    BBC iPlayer launched to some fanfare last Christmas. The British public were overjoyed at being able to watch programmes they'd missed, without being dependent on broadcasters' whims about when they get a chance to catch up.

  • iPlayer Radio review

    iPlayer Radio

    The BBC's iPlayer Radio app offers free access to live local and national radio broadcasts streamed over Wi-Fi or 3G on iPhone and iPod touch. Here's our iPlayer Radio review.

  • BBC Media Player review

    BBC Media Player

    BBC Media Player is, well, a player for the BBC's video and audio content that works on Android smartphones and tablets. Here's our BBC Media Player review.

  • BBC iPlayer on Nokia N96 review

    BBC iPlayer on Nokia N96

    The BBC recently made available for download to portable media players such as the Nokia N96, iPlayer TV and radio content.

  • BBC iPlayer 2.0 for iPhone and iPad review

    BBC iPlayer 2.0 for iPhone and iPad

    The new BBC iPlayer iPhone and iPad app enables television to be downloaded, read our review to find out more.

IDG UK Sites

Android M Developer Preview announced at Google I/O: Android M UK release date and new features. Wh?......

IDG UK Sites

Why I think the Apple Watch sucks and you'd be mad to buy it

IDG UK Sites

Ben & Holly's Game of Thrones titles spoof is delightfully silly

IDG UK Sites

Mac OS X 10.11 release date rumours: all the new features expected in Yosemite successor