We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
PC games software Reviews
15,670 Reviews

Dishonored: The Knife of Dunwall review

£7.99 / 800 MS Points

Manufacturer: Bethesda Softworks

Our Rating: We rate this 4 out of 5

A welcome return to doing assassination your way

Knife of Dunwall is the second add-on for last year's excellent assassination game Dishonored, and it's just what the doctor ordered: more missions, each with multiple ways to neutralise their morally dubious targets. The first DLC, Trials of Dunwall, had its charms, but its challenge maps were never going to be any substitute for exploring brand new parts of this world of magic, plague, short-range teleportation and whale oil-powered machines.

That said, only one of Knife's three new levels/missions could truly be said to be new. Of the others, one is a straight-up revisit to one of the later levels of the parent game, and the other seems to have been rather obviously assembled from bits of several others. No matter: while the city of Dunwall's angular, towering architecture is a big part of Dishonored's appeal and so it's hard to not crave more of it, even more essential is the simple pleasure of finding a way, via brains or brawn, into a place that your enemies don't want you to reach. That side of things we definitely get more of here.

The story runs parallel to Dishonored itself, placing you in the guilt-ridden shoes of the assassin Daud, the real culprit behind the regicide of which the main game's hero Corvo was accused. Knife of Dunwall's storytelling is muddled to the point where it's not entirely clear quite what Daud's trying to achieve or why, and an abrupt, hurried-feeling ending designed to set things up for the next DLC doesn't help things on the plotting front. But at the end of the day the goal is to neutralise a set of well-protected baddies and it's up to you how to do it.

Or, indeed, if you do it: the option for non-lethal resolution remains, and tends to involve more elaborate and satisfying solutions. It's all so overwhelmingly similar to Dishonored that it's easy to forget you're playing as a different character, despite occasional voiceovers from Michael Madsen as Daud.

That aside, similarity is only a good thing. After the rather one-note action of that other cerebral blockbuster, BioShock: Infinite, a return to the grand choice of Dishonored feels even more liberating. The new levels aren't that large, but if you're the type of player who likes to comb every nook and cranny, eliminate every enemy and pilfer every piece of loot without being seen you'll get a good couple of hours out of each of them.

Knife of Dunwall

And on a pure sightseeing level, the first level's a wonder. It would only be polite not to give too much away here, but suffice this mission means a closer look at the strange, sinister whale oil industry so essential to Dunwall's unusual technology. If you're a player who prefers methodically creeping alone the rafters rather than sprinting down corridors without looking around you, expect to see some dramatic sights below you.

There's been a subtle increase in the amount of enemies, or at least how closely they cluster together, and more daunting foes are now more commonplace. This has a palpable and positive effect on stealth-orientated players, as tried, tested and abused methods of picking off guards one by one are no longer quite so reliable. You'll need to think smarter, wait longer for openings and employ more gadgets to distract and disorientate. Daud gets a few new toys to play with, as it happens, such as mines which can either fry or stun anyone who treads near them, choking gas and, most entertainingly, the option to summon one of his underlings to lend a helping murderous hand.

Sadly, none of these things help to make the straight-up action experience particularly long-lived. Knife of Dunwall is simply More Dishonored rather than Altered Dishonored. So, as with Dishonored vanilla, while you can simply sprint towards your objective, stabbing and shooting anyone who crosses your path, you'll have each mission dusted in less than half an hour. It's a shame Dishonored can't quite be all things to all gamers, as was the original claim, but if all you crave is linear violence you're not exactly short of other choice.

Don't come looking for meaningful change, then - only an extension. If you are someone who likes to stop and smell the roses (even amidst the carnage), that's absolutely a good thing.

Dishonored: The Knife of Dunwall Expert Verdict »

Available on Xbox 360, PlayStation 3 & PC PC system requirements: OS: Windows Vista / Windows 7 Processor: 3.0 GHz dual core or better Memory: 3 GB system RAM Hard Disk Space: 9 GB Video Card: DirectX 9 compatible with 512 MB video RAM or better (NVIDIA GeForce GTX 460 / ATI Radeon HD 5850) Sound: Windows compatible sound card
  • Overall: We give this item 8 of 10 overall

A meaty and high-quality expansion - there may be plenty of repetition in here, but it is proof positive that DLC needn't be cynical and half-hearted.

  • Dishonored review


    Vengeance without a drop of blood spilled - or, if you prefer, gallons of it

  • Mass Effect 2 review

    Mass Effect 2

    It took some time, but PlayStation 3 owners are finally welcomed into the Mass Effect 2 universe. It's the same great game Xbox 360 and PC owners are familiar with, but with added bells and whistles.

  • Deus Ex: Human Revolution: The Missing Link review

    Deus Ex: Human Revolution: The Missing Link

    Is Adam Jensen's bonus mini adventure a thrilling new layer of conspiracy or just more skulking around man-sized air vents?

  • Mass Effect 2: Arrival review

    Mass Effect 2: Arrival

    Mass Effect 2: Arrival is the final DLC for Bioware's masterpiece, and an amuse-bouche for the incoming Mass Effect 3. Does it complete its mission?

  • Fallout: New Vegas: Old World Blues review

    Fallout: New Vegas: Old World Blues

    The third DLC pack for Fallout: New Vegas is packed with laugh-out-loud dialog, some awesome new items, and plenty of secrets to discover.

IDG UK Sites

OnePlus 2 / OnePlus Two UK release date, price and specification rumours: When is the OnePlus 2...

IDG UK Sites

Why I think the Apple Watch sucks and you'd be mad to buy it

IDG UK Sites

Ben & Holly's Game of Thrones titles spoof is delightfully silly

IDG UK Sites

Mac OS X 10.11 release date rumours: all the new features expected in Yosemite successor