We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
PC games software Reviews
15,670 Reviews PC Advisor Recommended

Thomas Was Alone review

£6 inc VAT

Manufacturer: Mike Bithell

Our Rating: We rate this 4 out of 5

A tale of cubes, friendship and why rogue AI isn't always bad.

You'd be forgiven for thinking from thinking from screenshots alone that PC/Mac puzzle-platformer Thomas Was Alone was either a scrappy prototype game or a ponderously minimalist art title. It's true that differently-sized blocks in a 2D world primarily made of right-angles is almost all it offers to look at, but it's precisely because its characters are such blank,faceless slates that they can end up with such personality. Their thoughts on what they're encountering and what they think of each other are spoken aloud (courtesy of a laconic voiceover from Danny 'Yes Man' Wallace), and with enough wit and verve to outdo even the highest-tech facial animations.

Each block is an artificial intelligence exploring the electronic world he or she lives in, and each has a distinctive personality of their own. The titular red oblong Thomas likes nothing more than to be in the company of others, while blue square Claire believes her ability to float on water makes her a superhero. Then there's tiny orange Chris, a grumpy miserabilist who'd rather be left alone and who's arguably the real star of the show.

Each of these (and there are a few others too) has strong feelings about their angular companions, but never expresses them to anyone but the player. Sharp, funny, often bittersweet writing makes their motivations compelling - within moments, the fact they don't have faces, voices, limbs or animations entirely ceases to matter.

What they do have is differing sizes and abilities. Lanky yellow John can leap huge distances, while surly Chris can't jump far but can slide into small spaces, for instance. The challenges and puzzles of the game come from using these abilities to get everyone to exits on the other side of obstacle and trap-filled levels.

The characters need to work in tandem to do this, usually by reaching switches in areas inaccessible to others and forming staircases or bridges to help their less mobile comrades along. Knowing that your flock of blocks secretly hate/love/envy/don't understand each other elevates these relatively simple logic challenges into characterful mini-adventures, a cubist take on buddy movies.

Generally, Thomas Was Alone finds a happy balance between mental stimulation and sense of progress, but its generally energetic pace can falter when it needlessly asks for repetition during a level. The staircase puzzle - using three characters of different heights to form steps to a higher place - turns up again and again, and having to do it five or six consecutive times within a single level just feels like padding things out.

Thomas Was Alone

Without such things perhaps the game would be too short, but that might be better than the sinking feeling that can come from looking at the level ahead and knowing you're going to tapping character switch/jump/character switch/jump/character switch/jump over and over. There are times when the game needs more variety of puzzles, not simply variations on the same obstacles.

Thomas Was Alone can also feel a little fiddly, with its requirement to rapidly and repeatedly change character often in the midst of danger, and that can conflict with the calming music and laidback voiceover.

Such things fade away in the face of the game's biggest draw though - seeing who/what you'll encounter next, how your faceless party's relationship with each other will evolve and what they make of the increasingly strange, dangerous situation they're in. As the game graphics arms race continues unabated, it's wonderful to have such definite proof that there's far more to truly compelling digital worlds than bleeding-edge tech.

Thomas Was Alone Expert Verdict »

CPU Cores: Single Core 500 MHz Minimum RAM: 1GB DirectX Version: DirectX 7.0 Graphics Card RAM: 1GB Graphics Card: DirectX 7.0 Graphics Card Shader Model: Not Required Sound Card: Required Operating System(s): Windows XP Windows XP, 64 bit Windows Vista, 32 bit Windows Vista, 64 bit Windows 7, 32 bit Windows 7, 64 bit
  • Overall: We give this item 8 of 10 overall

Occasionally frustrates, but Thomas Was Alone instantly and wittily overcomes its rudimentary nature with bags of charm and thoughtful puzzling.

  • Nelson Tethers: Puzzle Agent review

    Nelson Tethers: Puzzle Agent

    A delightfully eerie and expertly atmospheric game, Nelson Tethers: Puzzle Agent is a worthy debut for Telltale's innovative Pilot Program, even if it occasionally suffers from vague puzzle instructions and unclear hints.

  • Monument Valley review

    Monument Valley

    Impossible architecture in a dreamlike world - a puzzle game to soothe the mind and bamboozle the senses.

  • Monkey Island 2 Special Edition review

    Monkey Island 2 Special Edition

    Monkey Island 2 Special Edition is a textbook example of how publishers can pull old games titles from their catalogues and make them relevant again.

  • Professor Layton and the Spectre's Call review

    Professor Layton and the Spectre's Call

    Professor Layton returns in his longest and most intellectually stimulating adventure yet.

  • Puzzle Quest: Galactrix review

    Puzzle Quest: Galactrix

    Not only is Puzzle Quest: Galactrix an engrossing and habit forming game, it's challenging.

IDG UK Sites

Best camera phone of 2015: iPhone 6 Plus vs LG G4 vs Galaxy S6 vs One M9 vs Nexus 6

IDG UK Sites

In defence of BlackBerrys

IDG UK Sites

Why we should reserve judgement on Apple ditching Helvetica in OS X/iOS for the Apple Watch's San...

IDG UK Sites

Retina 3.3GHz iMac 27in preview: Apple cuts £400 of price of Retina iMac with new model