We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
PC games software Reviews
15,670 Reviews

Quantum Conundrum review

£10 inc VAT

Manufacturer: Square Enix

Our Rating: We rate this 3.5 out of 5

Massive invention and massive irritation in equal measure in this gun-free, dimension-hopping puzzler

With what we've seen of late 2012 and 2013's big-name videogames signalling a clear intent to be more gore-filled than an equipment malfunction in an abattoir, Quantum Conundrum's cheerful arrival is a timely one.

From one of the co-creators of the rightfully revered first-person puzzler Portal, this too involves figuring out physics-based challenges inside an elaborate maze of machines, traps and light-beams while an unseen narrator provides a steady stream of quips. It'd be lovely to review Quantum Conundrum without so much as mentioning Valve's famous game, but there are simply too many (presumably entirely conscious) similarities for that to be possible.

QC's central gimmick isn't a gun that can create metaphysical doorways between two remote points, however - instead, it ups the ante to four 'dimensions' which you can switch into to affect the physical properties of the crates, tablets, dodecahedron-shaped power supplies and numerous overstuffed sofas that populate the mad scientist's sprawling mansion you're laterally-thinking your way through.

The core two powers for the first half of this short but bargain-priced game are to make objects heavy or lighter. Crates and furniture in the 'fluffy' dimension can be picked up and repositioned to create new pathways, as well as capable of being flung across the level by trampolines or pinned against walls by high-speed fans. Heavy dimension stuff is immune to such flinging, and also can withstand being scoured by laserbeams.

Later, slow-motion and gravity inversion join the fray, and it's the former that's arguably the backbone of the game. QC levels are cavalcades of furniture flinging across deadly pools of 'science-juice' from robotic mouths, with the exit always tantalising visible but forever just out of reach unless you can crack the exact sequence of time/weight/gravity that opens up a flawless path to it.

Therein lies one of Quantum Conundrum's two main... well, perhaps not failings, but certainly elements that threaten to disrupt the experimentation and violence-free eureka moments it's founded upon. Given just how much it revels in surrealistic oddness, it's inflexible about its puzzle solutions - routes to the exit have to be just so, and attempts to shortcut by standing a bit of handy railing or jumping from a clearly man-sized box are undone by quiet cheats such as making certain objects intangible or forcing you off them.

Quantum Conundrum

Fair enough, it wants to impress with the flow and cleverness of its solutions, but there's such a thrill to feeling you've created your own path through the level. Instead, you're forever required to work out exactly what the game was thinking, and a clutch of inadvertent red herrings can over-compicate that.

On top of that, there's an ongoing escalation into dependence on jumping puzzles, with the logic element backgrounded in favour of time and precision of your flexes. It seems such a shame to have constructed so many ideas, and without any resort to the violence that infects the vast majority of videogames, but so often use them simply as a backdrop for whether you're able to press Space/A in a timely fashion. It's a game that in cartoon tone and pacifist nature seems to desire a non-hardcore audience, but the precision it demands means many less adept gamers will bounce right off it.

It does have some beautiful puzzles, where the flow and balance of the dimensions and the level's unpredictable but utterly logical reactions to them clearly stems from razor-sharp and highly inventive minds, but the reliance on jumping from the tunnel-vision of a first-person perspective, and resultant death and reloading until you pull it off, can sap the joy of it all.

Also again QC is the narration. John De Lancie, better known as Star Trek's trickster god Q, voices the disgruntled mad professor you're trying to rescue from the chaotic malfunctions of his own inventions, with you playing his silent, unseen nephew. He's not uncharismatic, but he sounds like he's reading straight from autocue and thus make a bit of a pig's ear of what should be zippy, witty dialogue.

It doesn't help that the wafer-thin plot goes nowhere, but the real trouble is just how huge a role the narrator plays - the only voice you hear, your only point of human connection to the game, but half the time you just want to keep shtum. It's hard not to wish that the game had put more time and resources into exploring its own ideas and less into providing a constant commentary from a celebrity of sorts. 

Quantum Conundrum Expert Verdict »

OS:Windows 7 SP1 Processor:Intel Core 2 Duo 2.2 Ghz / AMD Athlon x2 64 3800+ Memory:2 GB RAM Graphics:GeForce 8800 GT 512 MB / ATI Radeon HD 2900 512 MB Hard Drive:1.75 GB HD space Sound:DirectX9 compatible sound card
  • Overall: We give this item 7 of 10 overall

As a £10 game made by a tiny team in just year, Quantum Conundrum is well worth checking out and there's no doubt that we need more games like it. It's just such a shame it dropped so many critical balls - it comes so close to greatness but undermines itself with irritating jumping and unconvincing narration.

  • Puzzle Dimension review

    Puzzle Dimension

    Puzzle Dimension may not contain the story or characters we've come to expect from recent puzzlers like Portal or Ilomilo, but it still delivers countess hours of well crafted puzzling.

  • 007: Quantum of Solace review

    007: Quantum of Solace

    First things first - 007: Quantum of Solace is not the second coming of Goldeneye, nor does it really stand out amidst the other big shooters this holiday.

  • The War of the Worlds review

    The War of the Worlds

    The War of the Worlds channels classic game design to present classic literature, but perhaps should have stayed buried in the past.

  • Phineas and Ferb: Across the 2nd Dimension review

    Phineas and Ferb: Across the 2nd Dimension

    This licensed platformer is high on charm but low on content.

  • Nelson Tethers: Puzzle Agent review

    Nelson Tethers: Puzzle Agent

    A delightfully eerie and expertly atmospheric game, Nelson Tethers: Puzzle Agent is a worthy debut for Telltale's innovative Pilot Program, even if it occasionally suffers from vague puzzle instructions and unclear hints.

IDG UK Sites

LG G4 launch live blog: What to expect from the LG G4 launch

IDG UK Sites

Apple Watch release day: Twitter reacts

IDG UK Sites

Doctor Who scoops VFX gong at BAFTA TV Craft Awards

IDG UK Sites

Apple Watch buying guide, price list & where to buy today: Which Apple Watch model, size, material,?......