Let's get a few things out of the way. Yes, the Nintendo 3DS's glasses-free 3D is impressive. No, it won't make you cross-eyed or blind. Yes, the 3D effect you've heard so much about creates clever and often fascinating gameplay.
No, the preloaded games and apps and snazzy new features aren't slam dunks. Yes, Nintendo has once again built a piece of gaming gear that takes big risks, though while some pay off, others remain unproven. And yes, for the £187 Nintendo's asking, you'll probably want to buy a Nintendo 3DS if you're a steadfast Nintendo fan.
But only probably. If Avatar 3D wasn't your thing, if you couldn't care less about stereoscopic 3D, if you'd rather not fiddle with fussy menus or social networking apps or 3D pictures you can snap and share with friends, the Nintendo 3DS probably isn't for you. Let's get this straight, too: the 3DS may be less a gaming handheld than a totable multimedia centre, only one of whose activities happens to be gaming.
Nintendo 3DS: Design and build quality
Nintendo opted to load the 3DS with all you need to get started, plus a few unexpected extras. From a box twice the size of the DSi's, you'll pull an AC adaptor, the manual and setup instructions, a drop-in-place charge cradle, a pack of "augmented reality" cards (more on these later), and the 3DS itself, which includes both a telescoping stylus and pre-installed 2GB SD storage card.
Your first look at the system may feel anticlimactic. The design team traded the flush edging of prior models for an oddly edge-bevelled, slightly oversized top lid built to accommodate the dual away-facing cameras (used to capture 3D images) as well as the larger, more advanced autostereoscopic screen.
But place the 3DS next to the DSi and you'll discover it's actually significantly smaller. Where the DSi weighs a little over 300g, the 3DS clocks in at a trifling 230g - scarcely heavier than the family's slimmest member, the DS Lite (though still nearly 100g heavier than Apple's glass-and-metal iPhone 4).
Holding the Nintendo 3DS for hours at a time feels effortless, and my only complaint reviewing the 'Cosmo Black' model is about the glossy finish's tendency to smear (the alternative 'Aqua Blue' version seems a less messy bet).
Finding the stylus initially takes a few extra seconds, because it's no longer stashed at right or left and instead plucked from the system's top spine. The new telescoping metal material used in the stylus offers at least an inch and a half of adjustable length, allowing you the option to downsize for smaller hands.
On the left spine you'll find the SD card slot (for games and data storage) and a sliding volume control - a welcome improvement from the DSi's irritating rocker switch. On the right spine rests a sliding switch for turning wireless access on and off. It shifts back automatically, making it unlikely you'll accidentally bump it and shut down your connection.
The top spine includes the standard left and right bumper control buttons, an infrared port, a power adaptor connection, and the open-air game cartridge slot. I suppose the lack of defective DS systems over the years vindicates Nintendo's preference to leave these slots unprotected.
Flip the 3DS open and you might mistake it for a DSi. Both units have relatively spacious dual screens, stereo speakers, a D-pad and four diamond-pattern buttons, power, start and select buttons and a single facing-toward-you camera. The 3DS adds a thumb-joystick for analog 3D game control, positioned just above the digital D-pad and flush with the system frame.
It's similar to Sony's PSP thumb-stick, but larger and more comfortable over extended play periods. Nintendo also shifted the START and SELECT buttons to just below the bottom screen, and dropped in a 3D slider, top right, that lets you change the visual depth of 3D images or disable the effect entirely.
Nintendo 3DS: Look, no glasses!
Of course the 3DS's top screen - where it works its 3D magic by feeding separate images to each of your eyes - couldn't be less like the DSi's in terms of capability. Where the DSi employed a 3.25in TFT LCD, the 3DS lops a bit off the top and extends the edges, giving its slightly larger 3.53in autostereoscopic LCD more of a widescreen feel (it's technically 5:3 aspect ratio, or 15:9, instead of the more conventional 16:9). It's also capable of producing much sharper images with 800x240 pixels, or 400x240 pixels sent to each eye in 3D mode. Prior DS screens only supported 256x192 pixels.
What the top screen gains in tenths of an inch, the bottom 4:3 aspect ratio touchscreen loses, shrinking from 3.25 to just 3.02in diagonally, though it renders at a slightly higher 320x240 pixels. In fact it's just enough to yield discernibly sharper text and cleaner lines, especially tapping around the 3DS's new and abundant menus.
Getting the 3D effect to work properly - and continue working - takes some getting used to, and requires you and the 3DS remain relatively still.
For instance, you're asked to position your face away from the top screen slightly more than a foot, or about normal viewing distance, then remain perfectly centred at all times. But shifting as little as 10 degrees in any direction spoils the 3D effect and causes images on the screen to double or blur. It's not a problem for games that don't use the system's motion-sensing features, but it's a deal-breaker for others that require you to tilt and jostle the entire unit. If you don't keep your line of vision fixed perpendicular to the screen, you slip out of the 'sweet spot' and the image gets garbled.
You'll also find yourself adjusting to the effect each time you look away from, then back at the screen. Expect to suffer mild eye strain going in. After interviewing an optometric expert about the 3DS, I'm pretty sure time and repetition will eventually train my eyes to make the shift more efficiently and eliminate the straining sensation, but it definitely takes some getting used to.
Nintendo's taking no chances, of course, and includes 'Health and Safety Information' warnings that caution against children under six viewing 3D images due to "vision damage" risks. Not to worry, mum and dad, the 3DS's parental controls allow you to restrict access to the system in dozens of ways, from setting game access by software rating to curbing online interaction to regulating friend registration. And yes, you can disable the system's ability to display 3D images.
Nintendo 3DS: It only does almost everything
The system comes flush with preinstalled apps, including a clever-sounding albeit slightly daft little game called Face Raiders. The game starts by snapping a picture of your face, mapping it onto flying objects, then pits you against dozens of clones (what would your therapist say?).
The game even uses the system's 3D cameras to convince you they're attacking from all sides. Trouble is, you have to jerk the system around quickly to effectively counter, repeatedly pulling your head out of true with the screen and spoiling the 3D effect. (I'm told swivel chairs help.)
More impressive - though occasionally impaired by the same field-of-view issues - the 3DS can read "augmented reality" cards that use the 3DS's camera to transform ordinary objects around you (in the real world) into virtual thingamabobs you can fiddle with, or defend yourself from (yep, some even attack you). Imagine pointing your camera at a chair, then watching a garden suddenly bloom from the seat surface. Or a load of archery targets that you can only hit by getting up and moving the 3DS around (in real space) to find the perfect angle. Kind of eerie the first time you try it, but also pretty cool.
Want to make a Mii? You can (actually, you have to) but using the 3DS's VGA cameras to snap your face and come up with an approximation tends to produce avatars that look like strangers. I guess that's what you get from a 0.3Mp camera - the same subpar resolution as the DSi's shooter.
The new Home menu button serves as the handheld's "get out of anything" option, suspending apps or games and giving you quick access to other system functions. The home page it conjures includes an option to squeeze your apps onto one page (no more scrolling left and right), and the 3DS's higher fidelity screens keep everything looking sharp and tidy.
From here you can launch Game Notes (to scribble bits of info), the Friend List (see what your friends are up to), Download Play (download 3DS or DS games), a 3DS Sound app (record sounds and lightly fiddle with them), or an Internet browser (though the browser isn't yet working - Nintendo says it will be shortly via a system update).
Even the 3DS's menus offer the occasional thrill, such as when you're first asked to engage the 3D effect during setup. The 3DS lets you know it's about to happen with a suspenseful countdown. Then the screen suddenly seems deeper and the 'Nintendo 3DS' logo disengages from its static perch, floating out of then back into the screen.
The system still exhibits signs of a work in progress. Some of its features like the Friend List and 3DS Sound app feel underdeveloped and over-simplistic, while others such as Face Raiders and the "augmented reality" card games too often spotlight the field-of-view issue in 3D mode. We weren't able to test features like StreetPass (wirelessly exchange data with other nearby 3DS users) and SpotPass (hop onto wireless hotspots to download software and videos), both of which sound promising, but there's definitely a sense Nintendo's still figuring things out.
That said, there's never been a handheld quite like the 3DS - one as brimming with features as well as potential, and offering an experience that's frankly impossible on other mobile devices like Apple's iPhone 4 or Sony's upcoming PSP successor.
Next page: Our expert verdict >>