We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
Playstation games software Reviews
15,669 Reviews PC Advisor Recommended

Killzone 3 review


Manufacturer: Sony Computer Entertainment of America

Our Rating: We rate this 3.5 out of 5

Killzone 3 is Sony's latest attempt to grab a slice of the lucrative first-person shooter market for the PlayStation 3, but it falls some way short of greatness.

When I think about first-person shooters I always overlook Killzone. I like it more than other franchises like F.E.A.R., Resistance, and SOCOM, and I have played every installment, but for whatever reason it has never left much of an impression. In fact, the lasting memory I have of the franchise is that the bad guys are not too subtly portrayed as Nazis... in space.

Killzone 3 is the best entry so far, but it does little to alter that perception of the franchise. Relegating a blockbuster game to second class citizen status might seem odd to some of you - especially concerned PlayStation 3 owners who are no doubt already crafting their angry response e-mails - but the fact is that Killzone isn't as good as the current frontrunners, and adds little to the genre in which it competes.

I don't expect every game to innovate - only a handful do, and the rest work almost exclusively with proven ideas - and I don't think there's anything wrong with being derivative, as long as there's a tangible level of quality and polish, which Killzone certainly has. But the thing that bothers me about Killzone, and it's an issue that's exemplified by this third installment, is that it all feels just a little too rote and formulaic.

Guerrilla Games seem to be working from a checklist of popular genre conventions, so Killzone 3 occasionally feels like a greatest hits compilation of FPS "moments": there's the ubiquitous stealth level; a sequence where you take control of a giant mecha-robot; loud levels that take place on a massive battlefield and see you running from objective to objective in a mad scramble; an appropriately thrilling stand-off against a towering boss; and, in a sad indictment of the current state of the genre, an ending that drops you off a cliff without providing any real sense of closure.

At its best, Killzone 3 is thrilling, thanks in no small part to the meaty impact of each and every bullet. The jet-pack level also stands out as one of the better levels in recent memory, and I really appreciated the fleeting glimpses at the power structure of the Helghan high command. Again, the portrayal literally screams "These guys are just like the Nazis!" but watching the fascist leaders bicker was by far more interesting than anything that occurred between the game's actual heroes.

Unfortunately, the game peaks infrequently, and the vast majority of your experience is marked by frustrating, repetitive battles that are reminiscent of the worst levels Call of Duty has to offer - dying endlessly until you figure out the "right" way to tackle the enemies or force your way to a checkpoint - or middle-of-the-road skirmishes that don't stand out from anything you've done in a dozen other games you've played before.

And then there's the ending, which might be one of the worst I've seen in a long time. It does nothing with the weighty implications of the game's final Event, which definitely deserves a capital E. But despite witnessing, and helping to cause, this horrific outcome, the main characters just shrug their shoulders, the screen fades to black, and a credits sequence begins to roll; my befuddlement was momentarily counteracted when the "real" closing cinematic started, but it turned out to be a recycling of the proverbial "hand emerging from the grave" sucker-punch.

I know the majority of this review has been critical of Killzone 3, but as strange as this might sound, I never found myself hating the experience. It is just underwhelming, principally because it doesn't ever rise above the level of a good popcorn movie. There's absolutely nothing wrong with that, of course, but there's really nothing memorable about it either.

Next page: Our expert verdict

See Also:

More Game Reviews 

Games Advisor

Killzone 3 Expert Verdict »

Killzone 3 is only available on PlayStation 3
  • Overall: We give this item 7 of 10 overall

Killzone 3 is a good shooter that falls short of its own ambitions.

  • Killzone 2 review

    Killzone 2

    Almost four years have passed since Sony first unveiled Killzone 2, their vastly darker answer to the Halo franchise. In gaming terms, four years is an eternity, but Guerilla Games' gritty shooter is finally here to deliver a kickass experience that more than rewards us for our patience.

  • Red Faction: Guerrilla review

    Red Faction: Guerrilla

    We've fallen madly in love with Red Faction: Guerrilla - loaded with all of the content from the incendiary original release, not to mention some exemplary PC exclusives, Volition has struck gold with the definitive edition of the most explosive title of 2008.

  • Gatling Gears review

    Gatling Gears

    Gatling Gears is another downloadable twin-stick shooter for the steadily growing pile, and Vanguard Games offers little that you haven't seen before.

  • Crysis 2 review

    Crysis 2

    This Nanosuited sequel to the classic Crysis is a stellar sci-fi shooting game, featuring a gripping single-player campaign, action-packed multiplayer, and some jaw-dropping visuals.

  • Red Faction: Armageddon review

    Red Faction: Armageddon

    Armageddon marks a return to Red Faction's destructible Martian colony, but replaces the open-world fun of Guerrilla with a linear, run-and-gun treadmill.

IDG UK Sites

Acer Aspire R11 review: Hands-on with the 360 laptop and tablet convertible

IDG UK Sites

Apple Watch release day: Twitter reacts

IDG UK Sites

See how Framestore created a shape-shifting, oil and metal based creature for Shell

IDG UK Sites

Apple Watch buying guide, price list & where to buy today: Which Apple Watch model, size, material,?......