We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
 
PC games Reviews
15,103 Reviews

Breach review

£9.99

Manufacturer: Atomic Games

Our Rating: We rate this 2 out of 5

With Breach, Atomic Games is attempting to offer Call Of Duty thrills at an Xbox Live Arcade price. Does it have what it takes?

The most memorable thing that happened to me when playing Breach was dying. Destruction, especially if it leads to your death or the death of an enemy, is Breach's main hook, and it works rather well in its online-only environment. Flimsy shacks and wooden walls burst and crumble when damaged appropriately, which creates some satisfying ways to boost your kill count. I love luring enemies onto a bridge only send the whole thing smashing into the ground.

Breach is a bit of a one-trick pony in this respect, and nearly all of its attempts to capitalize on other first-person shooters' great ideas -Rainbow Six Vegas' third-person cover, Call of Duty's perk system, and even the Battlefield: Bad Company-esque destructibility - fail in some major way. Blowing up a bridge isn't so much useful as it is inconvenient, since it eliminates the fastest way across, say, two giant hills, and the too-sticky cover system often led me to an unnecessary death.

My largest concern is with the reward system: unlocking additional abilities and gear simply takes too long. I didn't feel like I'd made any progress until I'd scored enough 10-point kills to unlock my first 500-point rifle scope. However, this took nearly four hours because I couldn't earn kills as quick as I'd have liked.

Also disappointing are the rewards themselves. Few of them are worth their price - the Badass perk, which halves your energy but gives you double experience points, is certainly one of the weaker options - and the rest feel sort of phoned in. It's also aggravating to have to pay to throw grenades further when the grenade throwing mechanic feels unrealistically weak to begin with. Players shouldn't have to waste in-game XP to compensate for poor design.

Breach also has a handful of smaller issues that serve to undermine the experience further. For one, it's slow to the point where it ruins what could have been an intense experience. The visuals are so dark I had to crank the brightness on nighttime maps just to see what was going on. Finally, and most importantly, Breach is an incredibly limited multiplayer first-person shooter.

The match types are as typical as you'd expect - capture control points, kill everyone, etc. - with "Convoy" standing out as the main mode to play. However, if you want to fight your way across a map while escorting a vehicle, Red Dead Redemption and Team Fortress 2 already do it much better, so there's no real incentive to play Breach instead.

That's pretty much Breach's biggest problem: even if it's a cheaper Xbox Live alternative to more expensive, triple-A shooters, everything it does has been done better elsewhere. If it had contributed something new to the landscape I'd forgive its attempt at imitation, but its target audience already has immediate access to great games like Halo: Reach, Call Of Duty: Black Ops and Battlefield: Bad Company 2. With such a high standard of competition, is there any real incentive to aim so low.

Next page: Our expert verdict

See Also:

More Game Reviews 

Games Advisor

Breach Expert Verdict »
OS: Windows 7, Windows XP or Windows Vista
Processor: Core2 Duo 1.88Ghz or faster
Memory: 2 GB RAM
Graphics: Nvidia 8600 or better, GT240 or better or ATI HD 2600 or higher
DirectX®: 9.0c
Hard Drive: 1.6 GB
Sound: Any DirectX compatible card
Controller: Supports Keyboard/Mouse or Xbox 360 Controller.
  • Overall: We give this item 4 of 10 overall

Breach offers nothing new to a genre crowded with superior alternatives.

There are currently no price comparisons for this product.
  • Modern Combat: Sandstorm for iPhone review

    Modern Combat: Sandstorm for iPhone

    With Modern Combat: Sandstorm, the first-person shooter genre on the iPhone takes a giant leap forward... then trips over its shoelaces and tumbles into a landmine.

  • RAGE review

    RAGE

    The creators of Doom get their mojo back with this wasteland tale of guns, racing and, most surprisingly, people.

  • Natural Selection 2 review

    Natural Selection 2

    Natural Selection 2 sees the return after 10 years of the original Half-Life mod with it's own game engine. Does it stand the test of time?

  • 007: Quantum of Solace review

    007: Quantum of Solace

    First things first - 007: Quantum of Solace is not the second coming of Goldeneye, nor does it really stand out amidst the other big shooters this holiday.

  • N.O.V.A 3 for iPhone and iPad review

    N.O.V.A 3 for iPhone and iPad

    N.O.V.A 3 for iPhone and iPad is the latest in the popular sci-fi shooter game franchise. Is N.O.V.A 3 any good? N.O.V.A 3 for iPhone and iPad review.


IDG UK Sites

Amazon 3D smartphone release date, price and spec: The hologram phone?

IDG UK Sites

iPhone 5s review: why the iPhone 5s is still the best phone you can buy in 2014

IDG UK Sites

Passwords don't work: here's four ways to fix them

IDG UK Sites

Developers get access to more Sony camera features