McAfee Internet Security 2011 puts up mediocre scores in malware detection tests, but it's security software that can be had at a fair price.

Bargain hunters: Be patient and you'll often find McAfee on sale at a deep discount: The company's Internet Security 2011 (regularly £64 for one year, three PCs) is often available for as little as £20, making it just about the cheapest way to secure the PCs you have at home.

With that said, McAfee Internet Security 2011 put up mediocre scores in overall blocking, detection, and cleanup of malware.

In our tests, McAfee Internet Security 2011 turned in solid numbers in detecting known malware (98.7 percent), but the picture grows dim after that. It stopped just 17 out of 25 real-world attacks, earning it a distant last place in our recent tests of 13 security suites (the 12th place application in this test stopped 21 attacks). These results mean that it may struggle at blocking new, unknown malware. McAfee also had the worst false positive results in our tests, flagging 10 times as many safe files as malware as some of its competitors. McAfee's 60 percent success rate at scrubbing active malware components from already infected systems placed it behind the pack in that test, too.

McAfee Internet Security 2011 also won little praise in our investigation of scanning speed. In on-demand scans and on-access scans the application scored 9th and 8th place, respectively. But things brightened up quite a bit when we benchmarked our system with McAfee running in the background: All told, McAfee had a minimal impact on PC performance.

Into this confusing and murky picture comes the McAfee interface, which is a little unorthodox but still relatively easy to use. For example, the tool offers no readily apparent way to scan your system manually, but clicking either the "Real-Time Scanning" text or "Virus and Spyware Protection" reveals an option to do so. Cryptically, you'll only find scan options under the former text, although both will also let you create scheduled scans.

Actual settings in McAfee Internet Security 2011 are quite slim, and even the devoted tinkerer will find only a few options to configure them, most of which are fine as defaults.

In addition to the usual firewall and spam protectors, McAfee Internet Security 2011 includes a number of extras, including parental controls, an online backup tool, hard drive defragmenter, and a secure-delete data scrubber. That said, we aren't totally sold on the QuickClean PC optimization tool that's installed by default, what with its claims to "erase unnecessary files, such as old ActiveX programs." Are most users worried about their hard drives being clogged by mountains of ActiveX programs? Is anyone?

NEXT: our expert verdict >>

PC security advice

McAfee Internet Security 2011: Specs

  • Windows XP (32-bit) with Service Pack 2 (SP2) or higher/Windows Vista (32-bit and 64-bit)/Windows 7 (32-bit and 64-bit) View FAQ
  • 1GHz processor or higher
  • 800 × 600 or higher resolution
  • 256 MB RAM or higher for Windows XP (512 MB recommended)
  • 512 MB RAM for Vista/Windows 7 (2GB recommended)
  • 200 MB of available free drive space
  • Internet connection
  • Windows XP (32-bit) with Service Pack 2 (SP2) or higher/Windows Vista (32-bit and 64-bit)/Windows 7 (32-bit and 64-bit) View FAQ
  • 1GHz processor or higher
  • 800 × 600 or higher resolution
  • 256 MB RAM or higher for Windows XP (512 MB recommended)
  • 512 MB RAM for Vista/Windows 7 (2GB recommended)
  • 200 MB of available free drive space
  • Internet connection

OUR VERDICT

McAfee Internet Security 2011's solid performance at detecting common, known malware is enough to merit some consideration, but its dismal real-world malware blocking and over-the-top problem with false positives are enough to give us serious pause, no matter how great the deal is.

Find the best price