AMD's latest Phenom processors offer solid performance at a mid-range price, with the added bonus of lower power draw.

AMD's latest Phenom CPUs are fast, but not the fastest chips around. That distinction falls to Intel's Core series of CPUs, which are 5 to 10 percent speedier, clock cycle for clock cycle. Still, the new units - the Phenom X4 9950 Black Edition, the Phenom X4 9350e, and the Phenom X4 9150e processors - cost less than Intel's most recent chips.

The high-end Phenom X4 9950 Black Edition (CPU only) compares well, price-wise, with Intel's quad-cores, especially the newer 45-nanometer-process Q9550, Q9450, and Q9300.

Performance-wise, though, it's more comparable to Intel's 65nm Core 2 Quad Q6600 and Core 2 Quad Q6700. The 65nm Phenom X4 9950 provides a 4 percent speed increase (2.6GHz, up from 2.5GHz) over the previous flagship product, the 9850. The Black Edition CPUs, like Intel's Extreme models, allow you to increase the clock multiplier. Most CPUs are locked at a fixed multiple of the frontside bus--for instance, 12X with a 200-MHz bus, or 2.4GHz. The Phenom X4 9850 will now be available only in a cheaper, locked version.

All three new AMD chips use what the company refers to as B3 silicon, with a slight revision of AMD's original Opteron/Phenom design that eliminates a potential problem that reportedly could lock the CPU under a heavy virtualization load. AMD claims there were no reports of the problem ever occurring in a desktop PC; but as soon as the problem was reported, motherboard vendors implemented an optional BIOS fix at AMD's behest.

NEXT PAGE: AMD's green fingers > >

AMD's latest Phenom processors offer solid performance at a mid-range price, with the added bonus of lower power draw.

AMD's green fingers

AMD may have found a nice space for itself in the mainstream with its new low-power-consumption, 65W TDP (Thermal Design Power) quad-core Phenom X4 9350e and Phenom X4 9150e. The 9150e is slightly slower and cheaper than the 9350e - 1.8GHz to 2.0GHz.

Intel's Core 2 Duo CPUs are also rated at 65W TDP, but its quad-cores are rated at 95W and 105W. However, Intel's quad-core processors also run at clock speeds significantly higher than AMD's 9350e and 9150e do, so the difference in performance per watt probably isn't as significant as it might seem.

We put the Phenom X4 9950 and 9350e through their paces with a recently completed beta version of WorldBench 6 that tests power consumption as well as real-world performance. On a test bed with 2GB of 1066-MHz DDR2 memory, an nVidia 8800GTS graphics board, an Asus M3A32-MVP Deluxe motherboard, and two 250GB Western Digital WD2500AAJS hard drives in a striped RAID 0 configuration, the Phenom X4 9950 turned in a score of 104. That compares well with the mark of 108 for Gateway's GM5632E and the score of 97 for Commodore Gaming's CGX, both of which used Intel's 2.4GHz Q6600.

On the other hand, it fell well short of the average of 118.5 scored by the six PCs we've tested that use the 2.66GHz Intel Q6700. The test PC with the 9950 also ran more slowly than the Dell XPS 420 we tested with a 2.83GHz Intel Core 2 Quad Q9550; that system earned a WorldBench 6 score of 122.

For the low-power 9350e test bed, we used 2GB of 800-MHz DDR2 memory and the same striped array, with a much less expensive Gigabyte GA-MA78GM-S2H motherboard. Though the Gigabyte board features integrated ATI HD3200 graphics, it also has a PCI Express x16 slot, so we used the same nVidia 8800GTS discrete graphics board for a better comparison between the two AMD CPUs. For a 2GHz system, the Phenom X4 9350e's WorldBench 6 score of 87 was quite good.

The Phenom CPUs' power numbers fell largely as expected. The 9950 setup drew 227W under load over a 5-minute span, 3W while off, 7W in sleep mode, and 209W when fully awake but idle. Meanwhile, the 9350e setup drew only 162W under load, 1.6W when off, 3W asleep, and 147W at idle.

We used a rather beefy, 750W Corsair TX750W power supply for both setups, which exceeded the 9350e's requirements by a large margin. You should see lower power numbers for that setup with a lower wattage power supply.

NEXT PAGE: our expert verdict > >

AMD's latest Phenom processors offer solid performance at a mid-range price, with the added bonus of lower power draw.

AMD Phenom X4 9950 and 9350e: Specs

  • AMD Phenom X4 9950: 2.6GHz
  • 512MB L2 cache
  • AM2+ socket
  • B3 stepping
  • 65nm manufacturing process
  • 140W
  • 4GHz system bus. AMD Phenom X4 9350e: 2GHz
  • 512MB L2 cache
  • AM2+ socket
  • B3 stepping
  • 65nm manufacturing process
  • 65W
  • 3.6GHz system bus
  • AMD Phenom X4 9950: 2.6GHz
  • 512MB L2 cache
  • AM2+ socket
  • B3 stepping
  • 65nm manufacturing process
  • 140W
  • 4GHz system bus. AMD Phenom X4 9350e: 2GHz
  • 512MB L2 cache
  • AM2+ socket
  • B3 stepping
  • 65nm manufacturing process
  • 65W
  • 3.6GHz system bus

OUR VERDICT

If you use programs that take advantage of multiple processor cores, or if you often run many applications at once, you can buy four cores and gulp less juice with AMD's new e-series Phenoms.

Find the best price