About ten days ago I wrote about a bizarre issue with my iPhone 3G, where calls were being randomly but consistently diverted to answerphone. And this would typically be with the phone sat on my desk next to me in the office, merrily showing a 3G connection flag and full signal strength.
After information received from calling O2 Customer Support, and reading some ideas being bandied around on various forums from people experiencing similiar issues, I was led to believe that there could be an issue whereby the iPhone 3G couldn't juggle data and voice at the same time. If someone calls you while you're surfing, or even if the phone is just automatically polling to check for mail in the background, then any incoming calls won't reach you.
Apple still hasn't replied to my query to assert whether this could be true or not; but O2 did get back to me, and set about investigating the issue.
It turns out the situation is more complex than a design fault with the iPhone 3G, or even with smartphones in general.
There are issues with data and voice conflicting, but that may be more relevant to pre-3G networks. Such as EDGE - which the iPhone 3G also uses when it can't find a steady 3G signal to latch onto...
So O2's network performance engineers put a trace on my phone, keeping a log of my network usage over the course of several days. A week later, my claims for missed calls were all substantiated by the call logs. And this is where it gets complicated, as there's more than one problem at stake here.
At the PC Advisor office, on the Euston Road and directly opposite the British Library, there would seem to be something of a deadspot as far as 3G communications go. We're on the cusp of two 3G cell sectors, plus a third 2G micro-cell. And with no single cell taking dominance here, the phone is constantly going off the network, making me unreachable by phone. Not very helpfully, there's no indication of this on the handset.
The oxygen company's Network Performance Manager visited the office this morning, to test the situation first-hand. Sure enough, there's something amiss in this area, which could stretch to the huge pool of O2 users in and around the Euston/St Pancras/Kings Cross area. Or it could just be at 101 Euston Road. And the Pret á Manger coffee shop below. The company's best engineers are now on the case.
Meanwhile, my call missages at home in south London have been attributed to being in a fringe area, with poor coverage in a zone between cells. Here, there's a more credible reason, as signal strength is showing as somewhat low on the iPhone handset, and I can see the network constantly switching between round blob (GPRS), E for EDGE, and 3G data connections, all as I wander around my far-from-expansive top storey flat.
Unfortunately for would-be callers, it can take 45 seconds for the phone to be available again after every network switch. Which explains why I'm frequently domestically incommunicado.
I'm living just outside O2's key London 3G zone, an area encircled by the South and North Circular Roads. At the end of last year O2 rolled out new network infrastructure inside this zone to keep up with the escalating demand, principally from the iPhone 3G and USB 3G modems. This area is deemed the city's most important ground, given its high population density and number of tech-savvy residents and visitors, and should now get the best network coverage.
Ironically, I live just south of the South Circular, between two of the most powerful transmitter masts in the country, serving up a sizable chunk of the south-east of England.
Unfortunately for any continued chatting pleasure, these towers are not your usual mobile phone relays. They're more focused on analogue television, Freeview TV, FM and digital radio broadcasts, than on my personal chatting...
Once again, I'll update here when one or both of these iPhone 3G blackout zones lighten up at all.




Comments
pkansara said: This is Great Idea
sunpete said: Same happens to me tooon Bishopsgate near liverpool street the netowrk strength is full shows 3G as well but i tried calling myself using a landline and cant get through 2 out of 5 times I am sure people who call me would be annoyed
AH said: Hi Nas yes the interminable wait after dialling before you get a ring tone if youre luckyPart and parcel of the network - shall we say wonkiness - that some O2 customers are experiencing right nowIf anyone feels like chipping in with their experiences do put in an idea of your location - city town or first three characters of your postcode Will be interesting to see which areas are being affected
Nas said: I too have this problem Both my wife and I have 3G iphones and we constantly suffer from missed calls and extreme delays in recieving messages and voicemails My colleague has an new O2 Blackberry he also experiences this problem Its not on really when we pay however much we do per month I dont expect not to be able to recieve calls I dont know if you experience this but I also have trouble making calls sometimes it takes over 2mins for it to even start ringing other times it just dies
AH said: Update the situation with constant intermittent loss of 3G reception on the Euston Road may have been resolved after O2 network engineers made some repairs Thursday night Im awaiting the official line on what went wrong thereI think Im getting a handle on some of the issues with an iPhone 3G on O2s network and will post in full next week
Nefertari said: Not good not good at allI am looking forward to June announcements too and hopefully treating myself to an iPhone too but I cant stand the thought of not being able to chat and gossip over the phone
A.K. said: Very well done AndrewThe same problem has been happening to me for the past 2 weeks O2 suggested it was the sim card which I have now replaced with a brand new one but still no luckI have even noticed that even sms text messages take while to be delivered O2 said that they are not sure if it is the iPhone or the network and they are investigating But it is really annoying not being able to receive callsThanks for your information and looking forward to any other news
AH said: Hi Rob are you using another 3G handset on T-Mobile I was with Orange for 13 years and thought their coverage excellent but then again I didnt use a 3G smartphone until I bought the iPhone 3G last August Im not defending O2 so much as saying that adding 3G capability to existing GSMGPRS networks must be a challenge for all networks More so for O2 since its the only official provider of the iPhone in this country and that means a huge increase in data usage not to mention peoples expectations for full-time coverage everywhereThe sad fact remains though that when 3G coverage is poor for whatever reason in my experience with the iPhone 3G at least Im left with a phone that cannot be depended upon to receive phone calls And that hurts
The watcher said: Great blog man
Rob said: As someone whos gagging for an iPhone but is going to wait until any June announcements I find this massively disappointing Im currently with T-Mobile and find their coverage excellent Im also not in London so if O2 cant even get things right there I dont know what hope there is for us elsewhere