We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message

Linux breaks a market-share milestone. So what?

LinuxLinux has broken the 1 percent milestone for desktop market share. Here's why you shouldn't care.

Analytics company Net Applications has reported that in April, the percentage of "client devices" used to surf the web running Linux crossed the 1 percent level for the first time ever: 1.02%, to be exact. The firm enthusiastically noted: "Linux has reached this important milestone on the client as Linux-based systems have become more functional, easier to use, and pre-installed on computers from vendors like Dell."

On the web, you'd think manna had fallen from heaven. Linux backers touted the 1 percent breakthrough and predicted that Linux could eventually reach 20% market share.

My response: not in this lifetime. And in any event, you simply shouldn't care about Linux on the desktop.

Let's start off with why Linux will never become an important desktop or notebook operating system. Linux has been around since 1991 - a full 18 years - and is available for free. Given that, the recent "milestone" of 1 percent market share doesn't seem so impressive.

In addition, if you do some digging in the Net Applications numbers, you'll see that from August to March, Linux use was largely flat. Last August, Linux's market share stood at 0.93 percent and then gradually declined before picking up again and reaching that 1.02 percent peak in April. So it's not as if Linux is on a skyrocket trajectory.

Netbook dependency

There's also some evidence that Linux market share isn''t likely to ever get much higher than 1 percent, and certainly not more than 5 percent. The primary reason for the growth of Linux is the growing use of netbooks - inexpensive devices used primarily to surf the web and send and receive email. When netbooks were first sold, Linux was the desktop operating system on about 30% of them. Netbooks have been the fastest-growing segment of the PC market, which is why Linux finally broke the 1 percent barrier.

But Linux isn't faring so well on netbooks these days. Analyst firm NPD Group found that, by the beginning of this year, only 10 percent of all netbooks sold had Linux on them, and that number is likely shrinking. And Windows 7 will run on netbooks - something that Vista doesn't do - which means that Linux market share will drop even further when Microsoft launches a big Windows 7 marketing campaign.

How about Linux on desktop or notebook PCs? If you hunt hard enough, you'll be able to buy some from Dell. But apart from that, good luck.

Desktop Linux will simply never be popular enough for most people to care about. One big reason is the difficulty of upgrading and installing software. It's true that using the operating system itself is simple and straightforward - much easier than it was in the days when you had to be a command-line junkie to get anything done with Linux.

But when you try to install new software, or upgrade existing software, you'll be in for trouble. I won't get down and dirty with the details here, but believe me, it's not pretty.

Beyond that, there is no single version of Linux, and so by definition, using it becomes a non-standard experience. How many versions are there? I'm not sure anyone really knows. But these are just a few variants: Gentoo, Debian, Knoppix, Mandriva, SUSE, Red Hat, Xandros, Ubuntu, Slackware - and the list goes on.

The upshot? As a desktop operating system, Linux isn't important enough to think about. For servers, it's top-notch, but you probably won't use it on your desktop - even though it did finally manage to crack the 1 percent barrier after 18 years.

See also:

Why I use Linux

User guide: how to use Linux

Can Windows 7 boot Linux off netbooks?

Preston Gralla is a contributing editor for Computerworld.com and the author of more than 35 books, including How the Internet Works (Que, 2006).

IDG UK Sites

Android Wear update new features and release date: Google takes on Apple Watch with software update

IDG UK Sites

15 analogue facts that today's kids won't understand: winding tapes, Ceefax and more

IDG UK Sites

Disney's felt-based 3D printer creates soft toys and other squishy things

IDG UK Sites

WWDC 2015: What Apple will launch at WWDC 2015: Apple TV, Macs, more & how to get WWDC tickets