We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message

Why the iPhone can't kill the Kindle

Some tech analysts are wondering if the free Kindle for iPhone application will cannibalise sales of Amazon's Kindle e-book reader. A BusinessWeek article suggests that Amazon's no-cost app for the iPhone and iPod Touch may give consumers one less reason to buy the pricey Kindle 2:

"'In an economy like we have today, I don't see people shelling out hundreds of dollars for a device which replicates something they already have,' says Bill Mirabito, head of e-commerce researcher B2C Partners."

But while the Kindle 2 certainly is no bargain at $359 in the US, I doubt that Kindle for iPhone will cut into Kindle hardware sales one bit. If anything, the app may actually spur Kindle sales by introducing millions of iPhone/iPod Touch users to the world of e-books.

Amazon Kindle 2 review

Apple iPhone 3G review

Let's face it: reading e-books on the iPhone's 3.5in display isn't a lot of fun. In fact, it's ergonomic hell. The screen is simply too small. A few hours of finger-dragging and screen-tapping to navigate pages and resize text is enough to drive anyone crazy. The experience is akin to placing a novel under a magnifying glass and reading a few words at a time. Sure, a few iPhone diehards will dig this, but most users will try it and give up.

By comparison, reading an e-book with a Kindle is a pleasant experience. With its paperback-size proportions, Amazon's reader displays a full page at a time. Its large, ergonomic buttons make it easy to turn the book's virtual pages, and you can tap the screen to access certain controls. And its non-backlit e-ink display is far easier on the eyes than the iPhone's backlit screen, particularly if you plan to read for an hour or two.

Furthermore, Kindle for iPhone is intentionally crippled. You can't, for instance, access Kindle's blogs, magazines or newspapers. But since iPhone users can get most of that content via the web anyway, that's probably not a major shortcoming.

Overall, however, Kindle for iPhone is almost certainly a promotional effort by Amazon - an attempt to sell more hardware and e-books. Only users who are fond of repetitive stress injuries and eyestrain would read full-length books on an iPhone. However, if Apple ever launches a large-screen iPod Touch, then maybe Amazon will have something to worry about.

iPhone versus Kindle

See Amazon's new Kindle in action on PCA TV

Amazon Kindle 2 video

PC World US magazine

IDG UK Sites

Amazon Kindle Voyage release date, price and specs UK: a high-end eReader with Amazon’s best-ever...

IDG UK Sites

Why local multiplayer gaming is rapidly vanishing: we look at the demise of split-screen and LAN...

IDG UK Sites

How to successfully bridge the gap between clients and creatives

IDG UK Sites

How to update your iPhone or iPad to iOS 8: including how to install iOS 8 if you don't have room