We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
80,259 News Articles

Steve Jobs decided, 'we're going to patent it all' after $100M iPod fine

A huge patent lawsuit loss led Apple's late co-founder to decide to patent everything his company invented

Apple's late co-founder Steve Jobs made the decision to patent everything his company invented following a suit loss in which Apple was fined $100 million over the iPod, according to new reports.

Creative Technology, a Singapore-based company, filed a patent for a "portable music playback device" in the same year as Apple released the iPod, which had many similarities to the patent.

When the patent was granted to Creative Technology in 2006, the company decided to sue Apple for infringement, and the suit resulted in a reluctant Apple coughing up a $100 million fine.

Following the patent suit loss, Jobs told his senior managers that when it came to the new iPhone "we're going to patent it all," a former Apple executive told The New York Times.

The report says that Apple held monthly "invention disclosure sessions," in which three patent lawyers and a group of software engineers would meet and discuss their new inventions. "That's a patent," the lawyers would say.

"Even if we knew it wouldn't get approved, we would file the application anyway," a former Apple patent lawyer told NYT. "If nothing else, it prevents another company from trying to patent the idea."

"Former Apple employees say senior executives made a deliberate decision over the last decade, after Apple was a victim of patent attacks, to use patents as leverage against competitors to the iPhone, the company's biggest source of profits," writes NYT.

"Apple has always stood for innovation," Apple told NYT in a statement. "To protect our inventions, we have patented many of the new technologies in these ground-breaking and category-defining products. In the rare cases when we take legal action over a patent dispute, it's only as a last resort."

"We think companies should dream up their own products rather than wilfully copying ours, and in August a jury in California reached the same conclusion," Apple said.

See also:

Steve Jobs is missed, but Apple's stronger than a year ago, analysts say Apple dedicates home page to touching tribute to co-founder Steve Jobs One year on we remember Apple's Steve Jobs Apple files patent for wireless earphones aimed at sporty users Apple vs Samsung: Here's the deal that Samsung turned down

IDG UK Sites

How to get a free EE Power Bar: Mobile and broadband customers eligible for free smartphone charger

IDG UK Sites

Why Netflix won't terminate your account for using a VPN, probably

IDG UK Sites

Forever 21 denies pirating Adobe, Autodesk and Corel software, accuses companies of 'bullying'

IDG UK Sites

New Apple TV 2015 release date rumours: Apple's WWDC invite shows Apple TV