We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
80,108 News Articles

Windows 7, XP or Vista: which OS is best

Guide to choosing a Windows operating system

With three versions of Windows soon to be sharing the market, PC Advisor helps you decide which one to choose.

Windows 7: The solution?

Anticipation is building over the launch of Windows 7. Even with a beta build out in the wild, however, it's too early to say whether it's going to be an XP killer or simply a marginally improved version of Vista.

So far, we've been able to benchmark this first build and glean some nuggets from Microsoft about its general strategy in developing Windows 7.

Performance analysis

First, it seems Windows 7 is faster than XP - a feat Vista wasn't able to achieve. This means there's immediately a compelling reason to choose Windows 7, particularly if you're currently struggling with Vista.

Windows 7 has a simpler interface, with just a Start button at the bottom left and no Sidebar filled with gadgets that need to update themselves. Microsoft apparently dumped the Sidebar to claw back valuable screen space - a vital consideration if the OS is to gain popularity on systems with smaller screens, such as netbooks. Gadgets are still available by right-clicking the desktop and dragging them to a location of your choice.

Unlike either XP or Vista, Windows 7 allows you to easily rearrange the items that are grouped along the bottom of the screen. You aren't stuck with folders and files stacked in a particular way. An enlarged strip replaces the Taskbar XP users are accustomed to, and this is filled with icons relating to apps you've recently accessed and tools you commonly use. It's now much more like the Dock in Mac OS.

Microsoft seems to have worked hard to make Windows 7 more straightforward to use than Vista. Fancy ideas such as the resource-intensive Aero interface are absent (you can reinstate this if you wish), and Microsoft has kept preloaded apps to a minimum.

You have the option to install tools that allow you to manage your photos and your email, but they aren't preloaded by default. Listed under Windows Live Essentials in the Control Panel, you'll find items such as the parental-controls feature, the movie maker and the photo gallery, as well as email and blogging tools.

Share and share alike

Another useful difference in Windows 7 is the ease with which media such as music and photos can be shared. A password is used to control access to all items on the home network - now known as a Homegroup.

Printers, as well as content, can be accessed using a Homegroup, and Windows 7 allows administrators to specify who can access what on which PC within the group. A Homegroup is not simply a new name for a home network, however, as it can contain only Windows 7 devices.

The other change to Windows that will make a big difference to everyday use is that UAC has been toned down. Rather than a straight choice between being prompted to confirm your every action or to switch off the feature completely, you're now able to specify when Windows should alert you about a possibly harmful action.

Windows 7 also makes better sense of what's running on your PC, alerting you via its Program Compatibility Wizard if an application needs updating or isn't certified for use with the OS. Instead of simply whining that Microsoft hasn't certified it, it offers to find a solution, or try and run the program anyway. Given the OS's similarity to Vista, most programs should run without a problem.

We welcome the new ability to recognise and distinguish between devices you plug in. XP was always let down by its unhelpful lettering convention for attached peripherals, which forced you to work out which letter had been assigned to your flash drive, MP3 player or camera memory card before you could safely remove it. Windows 7 displays an icon-based map of what's attached and what it can see on your network or Homegroup.

NEXT PAGE: Windows 7's six editions

  1. Guide to choosing a Windows operating system
  2. Windows XP forever
  3. The future of Windows XP
  4. Windows Vista: could do better
  5. Is Windows 7 the answer?
  6. Windows 7: The solution?
  7. Windows 7's six editions
  8. The new battleground: netbooks
  9. Windows 7 specs checks


IDG UK Sites

Windows 9 release date, price, features: Microsoft teases new OS ahead of 30 September unveiling

IDG UK Sites

From the iPhone 6 to the iWatch and a new Apple TV we look at the products Apple is set to launch...

IDG UK Sites

September 2014 creative trends: 5 things you must see

IDG UK Sites

What to expect from Apple in autumn/winter 2014: iPhone 6, iPhone Air, iWatch, iPad 6, new Apple...