On Monday, some Facebook users were alarmed about what they thought was yet another privacy SNAFU by the social network: private messages from 2009 were showing up on their Timelines as public wall posts.
As it turns out, it was a false alarm. The "private" messages that were appearing publicly on people's Timelines were never private at all -- they were just old wall posts from 2009 that people had, well, forgotten about.
Facebook told TechCrunch that they have checked every report and have found no privacy breaches. Instead, users are just confused -- before 2009 there were no Likes or comments on wall posts, and so the posts look more like private message threads.
Facebook also says that there are technical barriers between the two systems that prevent such a privacy snafu from ever happening.
"The two systems are totally separate," Facebook said.
Though there's no real story here -- there's been no Facebook privacy snafu, and private messages are still private -- the fact that people actually forgot they'd posted personal-sounding messages on public walls raises a few questions. For example, how much of our online social lives are (still) on the Internet, ready to come back and bite us in the butt at any moment?
You see, Facebook's record-keeping process is like its frictionless-sharing process. In the same way that frictionless-sharing makes us bad sharers, Facebook's record-keeping makes us bad record-keepers. Certainly, it's nice to have a record, which includes major events and small, touching moments, of your life. But it's not quite as nice to have every moment of Internet-stupidity, such as the time you got kind of drunk and posted to 143 people's walls, recorded for posterity. Instead of giving us a digital scrapbook, Facebook gives us a digital transcript -- and it's usually not pretty.
And that's why it's a good idea to take another look at your Facebook Timeline, and what you've done over the past several years you've been on Facebook.
Here's what I recommend doing:
- Limit your past posts. Though ideally you'd be able to get rid of your past posts completely, if that's not a viable option it's a good idea to at least limit them to friends-only status. To do this, go to Privacy Settings > Limit the Audience for Past Posts > Manage Past Post Visibility, and click "Limit Old Posts."
- Cull your friends list. I don't mean you should post an "I'm trimming my friends list, post if you want to stay" message to your wall. I mean you should go through and look at the people you don't know very well -- such as old coworkers and classmates -- and determine if they're a security risk. For example, a loosely-affiliated ex-classmate who works at a company you're applying for might give up their Facebook login to their boss.
- Routinely delete old wall posts. Delete anything that's older than two years (or so) -- you don't need it, they're not literary masterpieces, and if you find a gem you can just copy it onto a file on your hard drive.
- Routinely delete old photo albums. Your 250-photo album of your trip to Spain was interesting and cool when you'd just gotten back from Spain. But now it's been four years and nobody cares, and at best the photos are a liability or stalker-bait. Get rid of the album (save it to your hard drive, of course), and perhaps post a "Travels" album with a couple of photos from each of your old trips.
It's hard to get rid of old Facebook posts, even if you know you're never going to look back on them and reminisce. It's also time-consuming, since you have to delete each post individually with the new Timeline format. To make the entire process easier, do it in chunks. Whenever you have an hour or two, fire up a Netflix movie and indiscriminately delete old posts.