We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
80,259 News Articles

iPhone & BlackBerry in patent dispute

Apple, RIM, Nokia and others sued in the US

A US patent-holding firm has sued iPhone maker Apple, BlackBerry manufacturer Research in Motion, Motorola, Nokia, AT&T Mobility, Alltel, Samsung and others for patent infringement.

Minerva Industries, which was granted the patent in question last week, only mentions the Apple iPhone as a device that allegedly infringes on its patent, but the company accuses all the defendants of "making, using, offering to sell, or selling mobile entertainment and communication devices" covered by its technology.

Apple iPhone review

The patent is for a "mobile entertainment and communication device" that has "a cellular or satellite telephone capable of wireless communication with the internet".

Troll Tracker, an attorney who blogs anonymously about patent litigation issues, calls the patent issued by the USPTO overly broad and says that its "broadest claim appears directed to a cell phone with a wireless internet connection, a memory card, a microprocessor, a display panel for displaying internet data". The Troll Tracker also notes the patent "has a little over four columns in the specification, but has almost 32 columns of claims".

The Minerva suit is one of several major patent-infringement suits surrounding wireless technology that have been brought against multiple companies in recent months. In September, for instance, patent-holding firm NTP sued Verizon, AT&T, Sprint Nextel and T-Mobile for allegedly infringing on patents related to the delivery of e-mail to mobile devices. And in November, Canadian wireless network vendor Wi-LAN sued Apple, Dell, HP and 19 others for allegedly infringing on its Wi-Fi technology patents.

For more mobile phone news, reviews and tutorials, see Mobile Advisor

IDG UK Sites

Acer Aspire R11 review: Hands-on with the 360 laptop and tablet convertible

IDG UK Sites

Apple Watch release day: Twitter reacts

IDG UK Sites

See how Framestore created a shape-shifting, oil and metal based creature for Shell

IDG UK Sites

Apple Watch buying guide, price list & where to buy today: Which Apple Watch model, size, material,?......