We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
80,259 News Articles

Apple blocks Twitter app from iTunes store

Tweetie scans web for obscenities

Apple has rejected a Twitter app from being made available in its iTunes app store because it contained obscenities.

However, there is a catch, iPhone Twitter client Tweetie doesn't actually include any swearing. The problem actually occurs with Tweetie's Trends feature, which scans the micro-blogging site to find the most popular keywords that people are talking about. 

If there's a naughty word in that section, it's not because Tweetie's developer atebits put it there, but because people on Twitter were talking about it. It's akin to rejecting the app because somebody was posting swears to their Twitter feed.

Apple iPhone 3G review

If that's the level we're looking at here, then Safari ought to be banned for indecency because you can use it to look at porn and Apple ought to take out Notes because you can clearly write swears in that too. While we're at it, we should probably just get rid of the whole virtual keyboard, because that's nothing but trouble waiting to happen.

Apple Safari 4 review

Of course, that's not the real problem here - his issue is that App Store approval process is fast becoming untenable. It's always been a black box, but moves like this one are starting to make it seem like a black hole. With over 25,000 applications on the store and more coming in everyday, it seems like perhaps the approval process is simply overwhelming Apple. Whatever the case, it's desperately in need of an overhaul.

Loren Brichter of atebits said: "As part of the bigger picture, this is going to be a growing issue".

"At the same time, I understand the App Store is still a toddler. I have plenty of faith that the kinks will be worked out eventually." He points out that what makes the rejection even stranger is that the previous version of Tweetie was a 'Featured' app in the store just last week.

So how do you solve a problem like the iPhone app review process? It's hard to say, exactly, since it's so inscrutable to us in the outside world. If it's a matter of sheer volume, then Apple simply needs to hire more bodies - that's relatively easy to fix.

Mobile phone buying advice

But I suspect it's more than that. The rejections that make the news often seem to lack rhyme or reason, which suggests a set of criteria that are not uniform between the various personnel doing the approval. There are a couple of changes that could help this situation: the first is to post a straightforward rubric for what merits rejection from the App Store - for both developers and those on the inside.

The other potential change is accepting more types of content and figuring out some way to rate or categorise that content rather than flat-out rejecting it. There's already explicit content in both the audio and video sections of the iTunes Store, but it's usually marked as such (although not across the board - you'll find a lot of movies that actually lack ratings).

Such a move could help avoid potential embarrassment in the future, too. From what I can tell, it would be a pretty trivial matter to get something onto the store that would only reveal its true nature after a certain amount of time. Widening the type of content accepted to the store could forestall that eventuality by providing a legitimate route for developers to submit edgier applications.

"It seems to me that App Store rejections are the rule when they should be the exception," says Brichter.

It's a solution that's not without its own problems, especially when it comes to overhead - unlike music and movies, there's no external rating body for software, so Apple would have to make the determination themselves. But that's something the company already does for both iPod and iPhone/iPod touch games. Perhaps an extension to that system is worth considering.

Regardless, the review process for iPhone apps needs to be standardised, and it needs to be done now, not later. Apple's created an impressive business out of App Store - it's time to stop acting like it's being run out of a garage.

Macworld.com

See also: 10 'offensive' iPhone apps Apple blocked


IDG UK Sites

Where to buy iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus in the UK: Launch day price, deals and contracts

IDG UK Sites

Is Apple losing confidence in itself?

IDG UK Sites

Professional photo and video techniques for perfect colours

IDG UK Sites

How (and where) to buy an iPhone 6 or iPhone 6 Plus in the UK. Plus: What to do if you pre-ordered...