We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
80,258 News Articles

Is Microsoft losing the open source battle?

MS gives with one hand and takes with the other

In terms of open source, we're never sure if Microsoft is friend or foe. We look at just whether Microsoft is winning its battle against open source.

Why Microsoft may remain conflicted about open source

Even if Microsoft's intentions toward open source - particularly those of Ramji's organisation - are good, several factors will limit the company's ability to act on those intentions. For example, Ramji's hands are tied as to what he can do to promote open source and free up Microsoft's licensing restrictions because not all of the company is totally on board with his efforts.

And because Microsoft's revenue relies on proprietary software, supporting open source - although necessary in some respects - is fundamentally a paradox for the company, says Eric Raymond, an internet developer and open source advocate who co-founded the Open Source Initiative.

Raymond says Microsoft will have a hard time reversing some of its proprietary strategies now, because much of its revenue is based on products such as Windows Vista and Microsoft Office 2007 that are a de facto standard in the market and can be controlled only because they are closed source.

Raymond says this sort of business model limits anyone, even Ramji and his organisation, who is trying to change Microsoft's attitude toward open source.

"He can be open only where it doesn't affect Microsoft's control of the customer base, and he can't be open anywhere that it might," Raymond says.

For its part, Microsoft seems to think it can continue to balance its interest in protecting its intellectual property - which the company sees as the key to innovation both for closed source and open source companies - with its newfound interest in coexisting peacefully with open source competitors.

"Microsoft respects and appreciates the great contribution that open source developers make in our industry. ... However, partnership with all software companies, including those commercialising open source technologies, must be built on mutual respect for intellectual property (IP) rights," Ramji says.

"All industry players must play by the same rules. Companies who distribute open source software also litigate to protect their IP, when they believe it is necessary to do so."

Even if Microsoft can no longer dislodge open source, it can still conduct skirmishes when its interests are threatened. But the open source community is now strong enough to fight back.

  1. The software company gives with one hand and takes with the other
  2. Real change at Microsoft in accepting open source
  3. Microsoft's mixed messages may hurt itself more than open source
  4. Why Microsoft may remain conflicted about open source

IDG UK Sites

Three buys O2 to become UK's largest network

IDG UK Sites

CarPlay and Android Auto: only a stepping stone to a fully connected car

IDG UK Sites

Microsoft's HoloLens hands-on review

IDG UK Sites

OS X Yosemite vs Windows 10: The Mac and PC operating systems go head to head UPDATED