Apple struggles with overheating MacBook Air

MacBook Air owners continue to report that their machines overheat and stagger to a stop when watching video or playing games, despite an update from Apple this week designed to fix the laptop's fan.

Earlier this week, Apple issued a MacBook Air patch dubbed 'SMC Update 1.0' that the company tersely said "fine tunes the speed and operation of the internal fan". In Apple's terminology, SMC stands for System Management Controller, which is a chip on the laptop's motherboard responsible for power management.

The SMC update followed complaints by MacBook Air users that began shortly after the waif-like laptop reached buyers in early February. Those reports claimed that the Air would overheat, then either shut down entirely or shut one of the two processor cores on its Intel Core 2 Duo processor.

Apple MacBook Air review

"My MBA would freeze up and then unfreeze and then freeze again, at an interval of about 10 to 15 seconds," wrote a user named RichardY late last month in a message posted to the Apple support forum. "This happens when I watch video on iTunes, QuickTime or even those Flash-based videos such as YouTube. CPU monitor shows one core shutting down itself when this happens, and the other core would run at 100 percent (roughly half for user and half for system)."

"After watch[ing] around 4 minutes of any YouTube content, the behaviour starts to show up," added Deny Dias on the same thread in a March 7 message. "The 'magic' number seems to be around the 163o F (73o C). When MBA goes beyond this temperature, the CPU bar graph of Activity Monitor show a slow down on core #2 while the core #1 raises up to the top." Other users noted that the fan inside their MacBook Air would crank up to flank speed, and make more noise than they wanted to hear.

The whole experience was exasperating to many users, although some took it in stride. "Actually, this sheds some light on the limits of this laptop. From the looks of it, its performance range is limited and fixed," said 'mac wison' on a separate thread in the same forum. "Which is understandable, as it's an unusual design."

After applying the SMC update, however, some MacBook Air owners said they were disappointed. "Makes absolutely no difference," said Pagemaker2. "My fan is exhibiting no better performance/quietness after the update. Absolutely nothing that I can see or appreciate."

The MacBook Air's teething problems aren't unique in Apple hardware history. Early versions of some of Apple's MacBook Pros, for instance, had a habit of sounding a high-pitched squeal, while first-generation iPod nanos came with scratch-prone screens.

The SMC update can be downloaded from Apple's website, or can be retrieved using the MacBook Air's built-in Software Update command.

NEW: Business Advisor

Visit our new site for the latest features, video interviews and buying advice for small businesses. Plus enter our competition to be in with a chance to win a Dell laptop.

Submit to:Digg Slashdot Del.icio.us Reddit

• FREE email newsletters. Get news, reviews and features straight to your inbox
• For videos of the latest products, visit PC Advisor TV
• Sign up for RSS to get the latest news and reviews, direct to your desktop
• Get PC Advisor news, reviews and blogs on your website for free

Latest technology news:

• British Library to offer 65,000 free ebooks in Amazon deal
• More companies look to virtualisation says Citrix
• Antivirus programs fail to stop new malware
• NASA's Endeavour blasts off on last mission to space station
• Toyota in Prius global recall after braking software fault