News
News spotlights:
Business | Digital audio | Gadgets | Games | Green computing | Home entertainment | Internet & broadband | Laptops | Linux | Macs | PC Peripherals & components | PC security | PCs & laptops | Mobile phones | Digital photography & video | Software | Wi-Fi & networking
News by company:
AMD | Apple | RIM (BlackBerry) | BT | Dell | Google | HP | Nvidia | Microsoft | Intel | Sony
News by product:
Windows XP | Windows Vista | Asus Eee PC | Apple iPhone | Windows 7 | Google Chrome OS
November 28, 2008
BT could be prosecuted over secret Phorm trial
Crown Prosecution Service gathers evidence
The Crown Prosecution Service is collecting evidence to establish whether BT illegally tested the Phorm online advertising system without users' consent.
The inquiry focuses on Phorm's Webwise system, which monitors a person's web browsing and search terms in order to serve up related advertisements.
An internal BT document leaked in June showed BT conducted a two-week test involving 18,000 subscribers in September and October 2006 but did not inform those users.
Privacy activists have suggested the trials violated wiretapping laws and posed data security and privacy concerns. BT maintains no laws were broken.
A Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) spokesman said the agency will make a determination whether there are grounds for prosecution at a later date. A BT spokesman declined to comment on the matter.
Phorm discussion banned in BT forum
BT's secret trials could have potentially violated the Data Protection Act, which mandates that personal data can't be processed without consent. The trials could have also conflicted with the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act of 2000, which makes it illegal to monitor communication between two entities without proper consent.
Digital rights activists have pushed for law enforcers to examine BT's trials. Alexander Hanff submitted extensive documentation on Webwise to the City of London police, but the agency concluded no laws were broken.
Hanff encouraged people on Thursday to write letters to CPS in support of prosecuting BT for illegal interception.
Other government agencies have also examined Webwise. In January, the Home Office declared that targeted ad systems with user consent don't violate the law. The Information Commissioner's Office, which handles data privacy regulations, had said it will continue to monitor deployments of the system.
The ruckus over privacy issues led BT to emphasise that users will be asked whether they want to participate. Webwise uses a cookie - a piece of data stored in the browser - in order to track a user's internet activity.
The cookie contains an anonymous user ID, which is then associated with certain categories, such as 'cameras' or 'computers', which then determine what ads a person may see on web pages that use Phorm to serve ads.
BT started another trial of the system in September and is attempting to get 10,000 users to enroll in it. The company plans to roll out Webwise to its entire broadband customer base, but no schedule has been set.
Two other ISPs, Virgin Media and Carphone Warehouse, are also planning to trial Webwise.
<<newer story | back to index | older story>>
Submit to:
Reddit
Subscribe to PC Advisor now and claim your FREE gift
Broadband?
Recent reviews
- Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen review
- ViewSonic VG2427wm review
- Memorex miniMove Portable Boombox review
- Logitech Squeezebox Boom review
- CMS BounceBack Ultimate review
- TomTom Go 740 Live review
- BlackBerry Tour 9630 review
- Freecom ToughDrive Sport 250GB review
- Freecom MediaPlayer II review
- Panasonic Toughbook CF-F8 review
Latest reader comments
- Why should we opt out? If I want my number listed I will use one of the services...
- What - forever?
- 'windows 7 looks like windows vista but it operates 70% faster and smoother and is more...
- Actually, your reporter is wrong. Reding was speaking at an event hosted by the Lisbon Council,...
- and how thell do you go online without a web browser if it windows 7 dont have ie
Top news
- By Royal appointment: the Queen joins Twitter
- Twitter blocks users infected by Koobface
- Mobile phone directory site breaks down
- Datawind launches £159 UbiSurfer netbook
- NHS affected by more than 8,000 viruses
Latest blog entries
- Google = Microsoft
- Open-source media player VLC hits big time
- What's your favourite job website?
- Is Chrome OS the future of computing? I hope not
- Phorm's just desserts and the future of the web
Sponsored Content
Latest technology news:
Sponsored links
-
Custom built PCs
Visit our website to see our full range of custom-built PCs. Customise any specification and have the order dispatched the next working day. A massive range of PCs - from £250 to £1,000-plus - and a full list of low-cost components are available. -
Software solutions that deliver instant comprehensive protection
ESET develops software solutions that deliver instant, comprehensive protection against evolving computer security threats. We pioneered and continue to lead the industry in proactive threat detection. ESET NOD32® Antivirus, our flagship product, consistently achieves the highest accolades in all types of comparative testing and is the foundational product that builds out the ESET product line to include ESET Smart Security. -
PC Tools
“PC Tools is a global leader in innovative software products designed to protect the privacy and security of Windows® computer users. With millions of downloads world wide, Spyware Doctor is a trusted, easy to use and highly effective detection, removal and blocking anti-spyware tool. “
About PC Advisor | Privacy policy | Media information | Site map | Contact | About IDG
All contents ©IDG 2009 | webmaster@pcadvisor.co.uk
Comments received
Steve Hankin said on Saturday, 29 November 2008
It's an absolute disgrace that this has not been before our courts yet. The very idea that a large coporation such as BT can do something which should be seen asa a break of the law (yes, criminally by interception of private comms) and get away with it is crazy. Public interest DOES require laws to be upheld. EVERYONE: Write to the CPS on this issue.
Fred said on Saturday, 29 November 2008
Here is more information on writing to the CPS and why it is essential:
https://nodpi.org/2008/11/27/letter-writing-campaign/
Kerry X said on Wednesday, 03 December 2008
I could never trust a company that employs ex-chancellor Normal Lamont as a director and, runs some of it's 'monitoring' operations from Moscow.
Ron said on Thursday, 04 December 2008
I'm all in favour of prosecuting BT over this (shame they can't be busted just for being crap), but SECRET? I don't think so. Unacceptable, definitely, illegal, probably, but not at all secret.
If there's anyone who doesn't know about the BT Phorm trial they haven't been paying attention - it's been widely discussed, even in the mainstream press, not just the IT media.
What we need is a court ruling, or legislation if the courts let us down, to prevent ANY ISP hawking its customers' private data to anybody at all, ever, without consent. Better still, just make it illegal to do it at all - period.
Pete said on Thursday, 04 December 2008
If i pay for my connection, then i want it all for myself it's my money. I don't want adverts hogging my bandwidth. I don't want to be told they only take up a small portion. It's mine i have paid for it. Leave it alone.
Allan said on Thursday, 04 December 2008
To Ron, Secret because they have *already* done it once!! This is over what they did in 2006. You are only reading about the new trial because they were busted!
redstringuitar said on Thursday, 04 December 2008
In the current climate of economic/political unrest, it is becoming increasingly apparent that large corporations operate under a thin veneer of civility and are actually run by immoral fat-cats who will stoop to any level that they can get away with in order to seperate you from your hard-earned money.
I would say that they should be ashamed off their conduct, but that would be like shouting at monkies for throwing s**t!
ISP's, phone companies, energy providers, banks and lenders have been fleecing us all for years and getting away with it by lying through their teeth!
Now we have to be vigilant, scrutinize these crooks and bring them to book whenever the figures don't add up. Something's gotta change!
Matt said on Friday, 05 December 2008
To be quite honest, there crap, there doing things illegal and they have already been caught doing this once before (2006) so WHY are they still up and runng?