It may only be 23 months old but Vista has been widely panned by both businesses and home users. However, it may yet become the world's favourite OS - here's why.

Windows Vista was released only 23 months ago but it's been widely critisced. With home users proclaiming their hate for the operating system (OS) and some businesses quickly uninstalling it, analyst firm Gartner has said the Vista is "collapsing" under its own weight.

Meanwhile, predecessor Windows XP has belatedly become so beloved that it's even garnering calls for 'unretirement'. But all of the griping about Vista and instant nostalgia for XP covers up a dry, statistical reality: XP itself was slow to catch on with users - maybe even slower than Vista has been thus far. For instance, in September 2003, 23 months after its release, XP was running on only 6.6 percent of corporate PCs in the US and Canada, according to data compiled by AssetMetrix, an asset-tracking vendor that was later bought by Microsoft.

In comparison, Forrester Research reported that, as of the end of June - 19 months after Vista's November 2006 debut for business users - the new operating system was running on 8.8 percent of enterprise PCs worldwide. Forrester analyst Thomas Mendel, who authored the report, wasn't impressed

But even Gartner, that prophet of Windows' doom, forecasts that Vista will be more popular at the end of this year than XP was at a similar juncture - with 28 percent of the PC operating system installed base worldwide vs 22 percent for XP at the end of 2003.

"The uptake of XP was slower than people remember today," said Michael Cherry , an analyst at Directions on Microsoft. He noted that many IT managers "labelled XP a consumer-only upgrade" at first.

Users loved Windows 2000, which was less than two years old when XP was released, and for many, XP didn't add enough to make them want to move up. "XP was really viewed as a glorified upgrade, not a new operating system in its own right," recalled Donnie Steward, CIO at ACH Foods, a US-based maker of processed foods.

Then there were all the security issues. XP now is considered highly secure, but that wasn't the case in 2002. That's when LifeTime Products upgraded to the operating system after Microsoft released Service Pack 1, its first major bug-fix update.

"We used to say XP was like Swiss cheese - full of holes everywhere," said John Bowden, CIO at the Clearfield, a US-based maker of recreational equipment.

To try to fix the security problems, Microsoft developed a second service pack, which it pushed customers to adopt. But SP2 was such a major change that it broke applications - lots of them, especially enterprise ones. That caused many companies to block updates to SP2 on their PCs for months until they could prepare for the mammoth upgrade.

NEXT PAGE: More reasons why Vista may still become the world's favourite OS

  1. It may be hated now but things could turn around
  2. More reasons why Vista may still become the world's favourite OS

Visit PC Advisor's dedicated Microsoft News Spotlight for the latest news on the software giant


It may only be 23 months old but Vista has been widely panned by both businesses and home users. However, it may yet become the world's favourite OS - here's why.

Some of the reasons cited for Vista's supposed doom are unique to the new operating system. There's the widespread exercising of downgrade rights by users who purchase PCs with Vista but then revert to running XP. Mac OS X has taken some market share away from Windows over the past year. Cloud computing technologies offer new competition. And the scheduled 2010 arrival of Vista's successor, which Microsoft is calling Windows 7, looms on the horizon. Both Steward and Bowden said they will likely skip Vista entirely and wait for Windows 7.

But other strikes against Vista are ones that XP has also faced and overcome, such as a tottering economy (the dotcom bust, in XP's case), the belief that it was a piece of 'bloatware', accusations of price gouging by Microsoft, and apathy or revolt by end users.

For most users, "change is always bad", said Merrie Wales, information systems manager in a human resources department in Glenn County, California, who oversees 250 desktop PCs. She said that only a tiny portion of her users welcomed a move to Vista this spring. But, she noted, a similar sliver of users was happy when the agency finally upgraded to XP in 2006.

And the Vista rollout "has turned out much better than we anticipated", Wales said. "It's not a bad OS. There are big improvements under the hood."

There are other factors that brighten the long-term outlook for Vista. Application virtualisation technology is giving IT administrators new options for deploying software and avoiding compatibility problems. And with Vista, 64-bit computing finally appears to be catching on among more than just technology enthusiasts.

In addition, history tends to repeat itself. XP deployments eventually accelerated, reaching near-ubiquity by the time Vista finally debuted. Similarly, some industry observers expect rollouts of Vista to pick up - even in the shadow of Windows 7 - as a Vista SP2 arrives, companies refresh ageing hardware and the end of mainstream support for XP next April draws closer.

For instance, Gartner expects Vista to be running on 49 percent of all PCs worldwide by the end of next year - surpassing XP's market share, which the consulting firm forecasts at 44 percent.

Moreover, most of the talk among enterprise Vista holdouts is about sticking with XP or waiting for Windows 7 - not switching to Mac OS X or Linux. Cherry said skipping an operating system release may merely be a long-term trend, not an indication "of Vista being a failure." And he noted that until companies jump off the Windows treadmill instead of merely slowing it down, "Microsoft still makes its money".

  1. It may be hated now but things could turn around
  2. More reasons why Vista may still become the world's favourite OS

Visit PC Advisor's dedicated Microsoft News Spotlight for the latest news on the software giant