We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
80,259 News Articles

Windows kills the Mac persecution complex

Opinion: Intel & Microsoft boost Mac popularity

Mac watchers have been writing about Windows a lot lately, following Apple's switch to Intel processors, and the consequent ability to run Windows on Intel-based Macs, both of which have profound implications for the Mac. It could eradicate the Mac persecution complex once and for all, change the outright hostility that many Mac users feel for Windows into shoulder-shrug indifference, and make the Mac more popular than it's been for a long, long time.

Trapped in a tiny box

Some Mac users harbour a pure hatred for all things Microsoft. A few refuse to use any Microsoft products on principle. Others don't really mind Windows but simply find the Mac friendlier and easier to use.

Wherever you fall in the spectrum, you've likely experienced the frustration of knowing that, as a Mac user, some cool products are out of your reach. Perhaps it's a new website that runs only in the Windows version of Internet Explorer, or a software program that has no Mac support, or an innovative piece of hardware that won't work properly when you plug it into a Mac.

Now, that frustration has largely gone away. Almost every day now, I play a session of Diamond Mind, a baseball simulation that runs only on Windows. I've watched hours of free streaming video, using Netflix's Watch Now feature, even though that feature is currently compatible only with Windows.

Is it inconvenient to switch into Windows to use these things? Sure it is. Should web and software developers support the Mac natively, without making us switch between Windows and OS X? Of course they should. But some of them never will. From now on, that refusal doesn't mean you can't visit that website, run that program, or plug in that peripheral if you really want to.

Fear of abandonment

When the Intel Macs were first announced, many commentators said that it would mean the death of the Mac. Once Macs could run Windows, the reasoning went, developers would stop developing Mac versions of their software. That hasn't happened yet, and I don't see it happening on any huge scale anytime soon.

I take some comfort, for example, from a recently unearthed 1997 Microsoft memo. The memo was written during contract negotiations with Apple. In it, Ben Waldman (then the head of Microsoft's Mac Business Unit) admits, "The threat to cancel Mac Office 97 is certainly the strongest bargaining point we have." The threat has grabbed headlines. But if you read the memo, you'll see something else: a group of software developers committed to making the best Mac product they can.

That commitment produced Office 98, an impressive release that righted a lot of the wrongs in the legendarily bad Word 6. Not only was Office 98 faster than previous versions, it was vastly more Mac-like. The failure of Word 6 taught Microsoft a valuable lesson: Mac users want to use software that works like the Mac, not like Windows.

That lesson still holds true today. The ability to run Windows software might give Mac users some flexibility. But if they liked the way Windows worked, they'd buy Windows PCs. Most Mac developers, including Microsoft, understand that. The ones who don't have left the Mac market, and good riddance.

Where to next?

If Microsoft killed off Office for Mac now (and there's no sign of that happening), it wouldn't mean what it would have meant in 1997.

Back then, the loss of Office would have meant doom for the Mac. If it were to happen today, Mac users could simply run Office for Windows or a file-compatible competitor.

The people at Microsoft's Mac Business Unit still have a strong commitment to releasing the best Mac software they can. The next version of Office will be Intel-native and compiled in Apple's Xcode development environment, a sign that Microsoft has made a serious investment in the future of the Mac version of Office.

And in the meantime? We can run all our favourite Mac programs and whatever Windows ones we might need. Who else but Mac users can do that? Nobody, that's who.

See PC Advisor's review of Windows Vista and discuss the new operating system with other readers in our Windows Vista forum.


IDG UK Sites

Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2014 tech deals UK Live: Best Black Friday deals from Apple, Amazon,...

IDG UK Sites

Why are people still buying satnavs? Smartphones are the modern satnav

IDG UK Sites

New Star Wars trailer: Watch the VFX-laden teaser for The Force Awakens

IDG UK Sites

Black Friday 2014 UK: Apple deals, Amazon deals & Black Friday tech offers UPDATED