We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message
Contact Forum Editor

Send an email to our Forum Editor:


PLEASE NOTE: Your name is used only to let the Forum Editor know who sent the message. Both your name and email address will not be used for any other purpose.

Speakers Corner


It's free to register, to post a question or to start / join a discussion


 

Excessive Force?


oresome

Likes # 0

Alan Duncan, a former Cabinet Minister, has said householders should not be prosecuted for defending their homes after a couple were arrested following the shooting of two suspected burglars.

Whilst I have some sympathy with the householders as it is claimed they had suffered several thefts, I cannot condone their action unless they were being physically threatened and felt their lives were in danger.

The only way to establish if the use of a gun was appropriate is in a court and politics should be left out of it.

Like this post
interzone55

Likes # 0

I think we need to hear more about this before we can make any judgements

Like this post
rdave13

Likes # 0

I agree with alan14's post, somewhat, but if someone deliberately attacks you or your property then they will be the aggressors and using criminal activities must face the consequences for their illegal acts. I wish we didn't make the victims of an attack guilty of defence.

Like this post
Kevscar1

Likes # 0

it depends, if the burglars were carrying any sort of weapon, if so then they deserve anything they get but until we know that it's impossible to say ifthe force was excessive or not.

Like this post
rdave13

Likes # 0

Kevscar1 It's about time that 'an Englishman's home is his castle' attitude should be brought back in my humble opinion. Fortunately I have never been burgled or caught anyone trying to break in. If it did occur then I would, no doubt, be shaking with anticipation, not thinking clearly, and be in the defensive mode, to defend all I have. Why should I be judged for that? I am being attacked and survival comes in to it and defend with whatever means comes to hand.

Wouldn't you?

Like this post
Bing.alau

Likes # 0

If this were to happen more often perhaps we get less burglaries.

Nothing is ever said about the trauma they cause other people. If the householder is hurt or injured in one of these burglaries then the offenders, if caught are given a slap on the wrist and carry on doing it.

I've got little sympathy with any of the burglars' relatives, because you can bet your bottom dollar that they approved of what was going on.

Like this post
interzone55

Likes # 0

rdave13

We've had this discussion before - if the burglars posed a threat to the householder then yes, an proportionate defence should not lead to prosecution. But, and it's a big but, if the burglars were not armed then the householder has no requirement to take any action against the burglar, and so any attack should be punished.

As we don't know what happened in this case we cannot pass judgement on either party at the moment.

Like this post
Flak999

Likes # 0

The CPS have issued detailed guidance for use by prosecutors in cases such as these. It can be found here Self-Defence and the Prevention of Crime

Like this post
rdave13

Likes # 0

alan14 To quote you " if the burglars posed a threat to the householder ", I can't believe that statement. Burglars are a threat regardless surely? They don't give a toss if anyone is at home or not and are the attackers. No burglary, no defensive behaviour, surely? Or am I missing something here pertaining to common sense?

Like this post
lotvic

Likes # 0

alan14 Are householders supposed to question the burglars to assess what kind of threat they pose before deciding on a course of action?

I am left wondering what you would actually do if you had burglars in your home.

Like this post
namtas

Likes # 0

alan14

"if the burglars posed a threat to the householder"

I would like to ask Alan what he would do if he woke up in the middle of the night to a noise and switched the light on to find two hooded intruders in his hall.

Intruders who have entered your house have crossed the barrier and are to most people a potential threat.

Like this post

Reply to this topic

This thread has been locked.



IDG UK Sites

Samsung Galaxy Note 4 vs Samsung Galaxy S5 comparison review: Samsung's best ever smartphones...

IDG UK Sites

Nostalgia time: Top 10 best selling mobile phones in history

IDG UK Sites

How Ford designs next-generation cars at its Melbourne Design Centre

IDG UK Sites

Apple 15-inch MacBook Pro with Retina review and the mystery of the processor benchmarks