Speakers Corner
It's free to register, to post a question or to start / join a discussion
Andy Coulson detained
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 4:29PM
I have a slight confusion with this case.
Given that Scotland has a different legal system to England which causes a Police Officer from one not having powers in the other, how can Scottish Police 'detain' and remove Coulson from England to Scotland?
I am aware he was not formally arrested by Met. Police, but 'detention' is the prevention of free movement which is what the Strathclyde Police enforced. The fact that a Scottish authority may have wanted him for questioning 'on suspicion' of an offence which is also an offence in English Law is immaterial to the detention/arrest until he is charged. Surely a formal warrant should have been produced in Scotland and approved by an English court to allow this action. Unless of course the voluntarily chose to be detained and transported into Scotland by Strathclyde Police.
Does anyone have any clarification on this?
- Tags:
- scottishenglish
- law
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 4:42PM
Here are the rules. They can cross borders.
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 5:13PM
The Gazelle and The Square Rig opposite the former GOVAN shipbuilders on Govan Road are very nice public bars.
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 5:32PM
The thing that I find strange at the moment, is why seven Strathclyde police turned up at this person's door just after 6am. And then it would seem he had to undertake an escorted lengthy road journey back to Scotland?.
Surely a joint venture between the English and Scottish police would have been sufficient, as would a simple quick plane journey with possibly one or two escorting officer's?.
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 5:46PM
The responsibility and more importantly cost must be borne by the Scottish force, much easier to send them down and let them escort the detained person back. There must have been a good operational reason why seven officers were employed.
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 5:55PM
spuds ...yesterday while waiting for my bus, I noticed two young (18-19 year old) uniformed policemen give an elderly gentleman in a covered mobility vehicle a verbal warning for some misdemeanor which may have been trivial, and then a written 'slap in the face' also.
I pointed this out to a chap who was also waiting for the bus, and he said that he got fined 50 quid for illegally throwing away a cigarette butt.
Coulson may have done something wrong.
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 7:28PM
In England when the police wish to hold you they normally arrest you. E.g. if you are stopped for drink driving the police arrest you after failing the breathalyser test and take you to the police station for the proper test.
In Scotland the police do not formally arrest you for many things but detain you. There is a legal difference but in practice it has much the same effect. I must say I am also wondering why it took 7 police officers to escort him back to Glasgow when budgets are supposed to be so tight.
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 7:41PM
As others have explained, under Scottish law 'detained' is equivalent to 'arrested on suspicion'.
Coulson hasn't been charged with an offence, but perjury is a serious criminal matter, and I imagine the case is complex - nevertheless, 7 officers did seem to me to be a few too many for the work involved. One or two driving, and two escorts might have done the job, but what do I know?
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 7:58PM
The Coulson affair will be the 'talk o' the steamie' in Govan...buteman knows what I'm talkin' about.
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 10:15PM
Perjury - an offence committed by a witness in judicial proceedings who, have been lawfully sworn, wilfully gives evidence.
Coulson and Tommy Sheriden who went to jail, are the people involved here.
Likes # 0
Posted May 30, 2012 at 11:13PM
When I got arrested at home 6 plain clothes in 2 cars. Mind you I do have a little bit of form ;-)
Reply to this topic
This thread has been locked.
Check out PC Advisor's other tech forums
Top 5 Most Popular
-
Samsung Galaxy S4 vs iPhone 5 vs HTC One comparison review
-
New iPhone 5S, iPhone 6 release date UK: When will the new iPhone arrive?
-
iPad 5 release date, news, specs and rumours
-
Apple iPad 4 review: is this the best tablet money can buy?
-
The 8 best smartphones: What's the best phone you can buy in 2013?



