Will the Scots adopt the Bawbee?

  john bunyan 21:54 13 Feb 14
Locked
Answered

As an English person who loves Scotland and the Scots, I hope they will vote "No", for many reasons such as the whole of UK being stronger than the sum of its parts - in particular it seems ridiculous to have separate Defence, Intelligence units plus BBC, Met Office etc. Cameron and Osborne are "hate figures" to many Scots so their views may not be popular, but the top Treasury Civil Servant has said a currency union is not recommended if the vote is "Yes".

Treasury

Salmond may bluster that this will not be enforced, but it seems that all 3 parties agree with the idea of not allowing a currency union. A threat to walk away from the Scottish share of the National Debt , if adopted, would mean Scotland would find it hard to find lenders, and rates would be very high. I guess the Euro would be unpopular, I wonder what the Scots voters think.

1]: [click here

  Aitchbee 22:06 13 Feb 14

I am a Scot. The Bawbee is a viable alternative, once it has been trialed.

  john bunyan 22:12 13 Feb 14

Aitchbee

What is the rate of exchange? Will you keep a few pounds, just in case?

  Aitchbee 22:26 13 Feb 14

jb - my finacial adviser will keep me solvent during the transformation of Scotland's Independance Transaction, no sweat ;o)

  flycatcher1 22:49 13 Feb 14

I have had trouble with Scottish Pound Notes in my time.

  wee eddie 23:47 13 Feb 14

I am going for the Groat. It's just that I don't know if Emperor Salmond will honour my pension

  morddwyd 09:16 14 Feb 14

The Irish Republic managed to keep parity with the pound sterling from the time of the inception of the state until the 1970s.

Why should Scotland not be able to do the same?

People forget, we've been through all these issues before in Ireland.

Neither the UK, or the Republic, went into meltdown.

  spider9 09:23 14 Feb 14

Strange that the Treasury suddenly allows it's advice letter to be published.

The note, seemingly, says no to any negotiation - but qualifies it by implying that it might be another matter if Scotland were to accept a longer term arrangement? (Salmond, last night, didn't seem too bothered on that score).

However, what signal is this sending to Scots, when the Edinburgh Agreement says that if a Yes vote occurs both sides will then negotiate to come to a friendly conclusion - now all three main UK parties say there will be no negotiations.

If I were a Scot it might well put my back up, when promises were made and then discarded - a dangerous strategy I reckon.

  john bunyan 09:48 14 Feb 14

"If I were a Scot it might well put my back up, when promises were made and then discarded - a dangerous strategy I reckon."

I agree; I suspect it will have a neutral effect - the worriers offsetting those annoyed by the proposal. What do the actual Scottish voters want for a currency?

  oresome 09:52 14 Feb 14

I do hope we don't get into increasingly bitter arguments before the vote that then make negotiations all the more difficult afterwards.

I also don't want the losing voters, who may well be a sizeable minority, to feel aggrieved forever more.

In the light of that I would prefer the arguments of the English to centre on the benefits of Scotland remaining within the UK.

I for one believe that the UK as a whole is greater than the sum of it's parts.

  fourm member 10:42 14 Feb 14

I do have to laugh at the 'this will alienate people' argument.

Put a different way it becomes 'people prefer being lied to'.

What has happened is that the treasury has told the simple truth that Salmond trying to make light of the serious difficulties of creating an independent Scotland is pulling the wool over people's eyes.

What ever aspect of separation you look at, you find the SNP's argument is deeply flawed. Look at what the white paper says about postage, for example.

I can't stand listening to Robert Peston speak but, in writing, he makes a lot of sense.

'negotiate to come to a friendly conclusion' Source?

Because what the agreement actually says is

'The two governments are committed to continue to work together constructively in the light of the outcome, whatever it is, in the best interests of the people of Scotland and of the rest of the United Kingdom.'

It is hardly in the interests of the UK to give a blank cheque to bail out Scotland in the circumstances Peston describes.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Nintendo Switch review: Hands-on with the intuitive modular console and its disappointing games…

1995-2015: How technology has changed the world in 20 years

Prehistoric Britain is laid out in these Royal Mail stamp illustrations

Best running headphones | Best sport & fitness headphones: 4 brilliant pairs of wireless…