Tomato's don't have a smell

  wee eddie 16:17 21 May 15
Locked
Answered

I noticed something the other day. Tomato's don't have a smell.

Now you may say that: When I grow tomatoes there is a marvellous aroma in the greenhouse, and I don't contest that. What I am saying is that the smell is not coming from the tomato itself ~~~~ it is coming from the plant and, in particular, the stalk immediately adjacent to the Tomato.

Think about it, I'm prepared to be proved wrong, shot down in flames, whatever!

Perhaps, to give our salad dressing that particular aroma, we should scrape the stalk and add the scrapings to our dressing

  johnincrete 16:26 21 May 15

Firstly, the plural of tomato does not need an apostrophe!

Here in Crete, we are getting greenhouse grown tomatoes and there is little smell but still lots of sweet taste. Come the season, the way to tell how fresh the tomato is is to smell it. One or two days since picking has a good smell. No smell means don't buy.

  Aitchbee 18:11 21 May 15

Ah, but newly-opened-peeled-tinned-tomatoes [ Italian - pomodoro pelati ] always have a distinct tomatoey aroma ... fantastico!

  namtas 18:55 21 May 15

My home grown tomatoes actually do have a smell and it is rather special and unique, when I take a fresh ripe tomato from the plant and cup it in one hand and smell the aroma is quite distinctive, Only rarely have I had this from tomatoes which I have bought.

  bumpkin 21:34 21 May 15

Behold the resurrection of the great tinned tomatoes.

Nice one, had me laughing but little else going on here:-)

  Forum Editor 22:18 21 May 15

Resurrection of the great tinned tomatoes? Not on my watch.

I had more than enough of that last time.

  morddwyd 07:45 22 May 15

Smell more when they're really fresh I find.

Cherry tomatoes seem to have a bit more smell (and flavour, I eat them like sweets!).

  Forum Editor 10:50 22 May 15
Answer

When I Pick tomatoes off the vine they do have that classic scent, but I tend to thinkit comes from the stem, rather from the fruit itself (never refer to tomatoes as a vegetable).

When this summer's crop comes in I'll remember to do some proper tests.

  Belatucadrus 12:24 22 May 15

Just tested it :-

Tomatoes sold without vine virtually odour free, there is a slight aroma when they're cut.

Tomatoes sold on the vine definitely have an aroma but I suspect FE is correct in that it's more transfer of aromatic oils from the stem than any inherent smell from the fruits themselves.

Tomato vine & leaves powerfully aromatic and the smell does get on your fingers when you handle them.

With the usual caveat that there are a shed load of tomato varieties and I suspect they vary quite a bit.

  wee eddie 14:26 22 May 15

It's something that's fascinated me since childhood.

My father used to grow many varieties of tomato, large, small, red, yellow and striped. The greenhouse used to smell wonderful but when the fruit were individually brought inside, to ripen off, there was no, or almost no, smell at all.

Thanks FE; I shall await the conclusion of your test, if not with bated breath, at least with a degree of trepidation.

  SeiyaIkki 14:30 22 May 15

Tomato's don't have smell... but Toma-toes have!

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Sony Xperia XZ Premium review: Hands-on with the new 4K HDR phone with Motion Eye camera and Snapdr5…

1995-2015: How technology has changed the world in 20 years

Best laptop for design and art 2017: we test Apple, Dell, HP, Lenovo and Microsoft's best models…

CarPlay tips & troubleshooting guide: CarPlay tips & troubleshooting guide: Get the most from…