Puzzled of Edinburgh....

  gengiscant 20 Oct 11
Locked

Why do the media, press/TV and politicians, when they want to show that their parties policies include being tough on crime continually report that any neerdowell,(selected as my favorite word of the day), crook,criminal,the odd politician, never a banker, when receiving a prison sentence tell us total years a judge has given. When in reality it is a lot less and in many many cases these people do less than half the term?

  wiz-king 20 Oct 11

Because the Judges sentence can/will be modified by the governments policy or at the whims of the civil service.

  interzone55 20 Oct 11

Because this is the maximum sentence the convicted person will serve, any time spent on remand is taken off this sentence straight away, then any further reductions depend on a number of factors, such as good behaviour in prison (admitting guilt, showing genuine remorse, attending therapy etc).

You have to realise that if every prisoner spent their whole sentence inside we'd need many more prisons for a start, and there would be absolutely no incentive for many (not most, as most prisoners are generally well behaved inside) prisoners to act like human beings inside. You'd have a prison system like the US where the convicts are treated like animals, so they behave like animals.

  Kevscar1 20 Oct 11

or they are animals and get treated as such rather than molly coddled

  interzone55 20 Oct 11

Kevscar

No one could accuse you of being a wishy washy liberal.

The fact is that if you treat people well, not in luxury, but treat them as fellow human beings, they respond in kind.

Yes you are in prison as a punishment, but just removing their liberty is enough punishment for most offenders.

  gengiscant 20 Oct 11

alan14

Yes you are in prison as a punishment, but just removing their liberty is enough punishment for most offenders.

I don't think so.Re-offending rates top 70% in some prisons and overall 50% of prisoners re-offend.

  Graphicool1 20 Oct 11

gengiscant

"Re-offending rates top 70% in some prisons and overall 50% of prisoners re-offend."

The fact that once released from prison they then have a record, might just have something to do with that. Perhaps the powers that be should also find them a job to be released to. That's not to say that they should get preferencial treatment over law abiding citizens.

Here is just one idea that I've had, perhaps for the first year on the outside, they could be released into the custody of an open prison and wear ankle monitors. The jobs they could do would be the sort that used to be called menial, servial and degrading. Cleaners of toilets, bad graffiti, removing chewing gum, from pavements, dog ends, dog poo, late night revellers vomit.

If the sort of scum that would contemplate premeditated theft and violence were to be made aware that a year of this would be waiting for them after they left prison. It might just go some way toward making them think twice in the first place. Just the thought of the humiliation they would have to endure. It would - in my opinion - go a long way toward robbing them of any cudos that they might otherwise have got from their homies.

  morddwyd 20 Oct 11

"The fact is that if you treat people well, not in luxury, but treat them as fellow human beings, they respond in kind"

I'm afraid that is not "a fact".

Some will respond in this way, others will see it as a sign of weakness and take advantage.

  badgery 20 Oct 11

gengiscant "*removing their liberty is enough punishment for most offenders. I don't think so*"

If removal of liberty is not enough punishment in your eyes, just what would you want? Regular beatings, maybe?

It's easy to say prisoners are molly-coddled when you are sitting outside prison.

  gengiscant 20 Oct 11

Badgery

I cannot see anywhere in my posts when I have used the word "Molly-coddled". But you are quite right I do not think that prison is particularly hard these days and I do not think I need to experience prison life to have an opinion on it. Or perhaps you are of a different view.

  interzone55 20 Oct 11

gengiscant

But you are quite right I do not think that prison is particularly hard these days and I do not think I need to experience prison life to have an opinion on it.

So you're psychic?

I've never been locked up, but I have visited several prisons, and they're not very nice places at all.

There is a constant air of violence, rather like being in a pub in the wrong part of town, but without the alcohol (well not in plain sight anyway)...

Advertisement

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Should I upgrade to Windows 10? 8 reasons why you should upgrade to Windows 10... and 2 why you…

We are being sold the ability to spend money we don't have. And we love it

IKinema aims to banish droopy shoulders and wonky spines in animated CG characters

How to use Apple Music in the UK: Complete guide to Apple Music's features

We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. If you continue to use this site, we'll assume you're happy with this. Alternatively, click here to find out how to manage these cookies

hide cookie message