You are obviously trying to use CD copy. (Illegal?)
Making one back up copy for your personal use is tolerated by the music industry. (See site usage policy [just covering PCA's a***])
You need to "rip" the music files from the Album then burn to two CDs. This gives the advantage that you can reorder or miss off tracks or even add tracks from other albums to make your own compilations.
I use Music Match Jukebox, Itunes will also let you rip plus there are several more progs out there on the net.