Personally I much prefer the look of the new site to the old one. The design seems much more coherent, particularly the colour scheme. The new format of the link menu on the right is much better - it fits in with the rest of the page. I think the photo gallery and the forum are especially good features. A few things I noticed:
- you're missing titles on a few of the pages. "Club history", for example, is an untitled document
- in the menu bar, the link text overlaps the football images a little. I'm not sure if this is deliberate.
- you could stand to float the text a tiny bit further away from the images, if possible. For example, on the home page, the text around the Eddie Harper picture could move a couple of pixels to the right.
- in the forum, the red text on the white background is a bit difficult to read - maybe a slightly darker shade of red?
This is all really nit-picking - the new site looks very nice.
The only other thing I'd suggest would be using CSS to style your pages (tutorials : click here). It makes it easier to play around with format and layout when designing pages.