External hard drives for backup. Which type?

  Simsy 12:46 18 Aug 06


I have various backup provision myself, including an external HDD in a caddy...

I'm in the process of helping/advising a colleague with a purchase...

Can anyone advise the pros/cons, comparing;

purpose bulit external HD.


HD in an external caddy.

both being USB. Thanks in anticipation,



  Jak_1 14:49 18 Aug 06

The caddy is the better option for two reasons:

1. Internal drives to fit are cheaper.
2. You can swap drives in the caddy thereby being able to use seperate drives for backup if you have more than one hdd.

  Simsy 15:56 18 Aug 06

Any opposing views?

Thanks in anticipation,



  Spark6 16:09 18 Aug 06

Some external drives are annoyingly noisy, I would suggest that you or your colleague try some out for yourselves or obtain recommendations. I have one that I use as little as possible.

  pj123 16:46 18 Aug 06

I use ordinary bog-standard IDE hard drives to back up two computers.

I bought this unit, which will also handle 2.5 inch (laptop?) hard drives and also CD/DVD drives.

click here

Works great.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Nintendo Switch review: Hands on with the intuitive modular console and its disappointing games…

1995-2015: How technology has changed the world in 20 years

Here's what should be coming to Adobe Project Felix in 2017

Apple AirPods review: Apple's beautiful new Bluetooth headphones bring true intelligence to…