Digital Photography

  Newuser939 10:25 AM 16 Aug 11

I have a digital camera which can take pictures in RAW format or JPEG. I appreciate that one advantage of JPEG is that because of file size, a lot more photos can fit on a memory card, but now that memory cards are getting fairly inexpensive for large capacities, that is not as significant a factor as it used to be. In theory, RAW files should allow a much better final picture to be produced as a JPEG file will already have discarded a lot of the original information. However, I just wonder whether anyone has done any comparisons to ascertain whether that theoretical advantage is significant in practice.

  mimosa418 12:21 PM 16 Aug 11

You should read this

  woodchip 14:20 PM 16 Aug 11

Edit in Raw save final in Jpeg

  Newuser939 18:54 PM 16 Aug 11

Thanks for the answers. Looking at the article and subsequent comments in mimosa418's link, the conclusion to be drawn seems to be that expert photographers will manage perfectly well with just JPEG, but the rest of us are probably safer sticking with RAW, which makes woodchip's suggestion very sensible.

  woodchip 18:59 PM 16 Aug 11

Raw are bigger files with more info in them Jpeg saving after you edit will not lose as much detail in the photo.

  woodchip 19:00 PM 16 Aug 11

PS what I mean is do all your Editing first in Raw, before the final Save to Jpeg

  hssutton 20:01 PM 16 Aug 11

If you are a 'photographer' who when shooting with film have them processed at the local chemist. Then Jpeg is the way to go, because quality was never really an issue with you.

If however quality is an issue, then Raw is the way to go. The latitude of digital cameras is the limitation. If you have blown highlights or no detail in the shadows, or the white balance is out, or exposure is incorrect then your jpeg photo is ruined. With Raw these problems can be overcome.

Memory is now so cheap I would'nt worry to much about file sizes. I have an 18Mp DSLR and can get a little over 300 shots from an 8Mb flash card when shooting raw

You followed Mimosas link now read this one raw v jpeg

  matofthemint 12:28 PM 17 Aug 11

I suggest that you save your final work on a foto in TIFF - no loss if you should have to do further work.


This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Best Black Friday deals 2015 live blog: Best UK Black Friday deals & best UK Black Friday tech…

1995-2015: How technology has changed the world in 20 years

This 4K screen is purpose-built for showcasing digital art

20 Mac Power User Tricks... That You Didn't Know