BT and Plusnet Modems

  Newuser939 11:08 17 Dec 12

I am currently with BT for telephone and broadband, but could get a similar package from Plusnet for about £6 a month less.However, I see that BT claim that the Home Hub is worth £99 but Plusnet only claim that their router is worth half that. There must be differences between them, but would I notice those differences in practice?

  Phil Ocifer 12:32 17 Dec 12

. . . and both of them probably only cost 50p to manufacture in the far east (and probably cost BT twice as much to purchase!!)

BT have to justify their massive monthly charges so telling us that their modem is worth £99 is just part of the big con (imho).

Mind you, it's a good job BT are there - it gives others like TT and PlusNet a good starting point for price comparisons where they can state "Save over £110 against BTs 18 month contract). I notice TT doesn't use PlusNet in their comparison table, just the three most expensive ISPs.

(btw, I thought PlusNet were part of BT?)

No, you probably will not notice much difference in practice, although you might even get a better speed from one or the other depending on which ISPs have been LLUd at your local exchange. Google samknows and your local exchange name.

  Secret-Squirrel 12:36 17 Dec 12

I'll make it easy for you - don't bother getting a Home Hub as I've found them mostly unreliable and temperamental.

I've fixed a lot of broadband and wireless problems and other glitches over the last two years or so by replacing the user's Home Hub with one of these. Don't let the cheap price put you off as that particular model is an excellent performer. If you decide to buy one from that webpage then I'd recommend you choose the option to buy direct from Amazon rather than one of their third-party "Marketplace" sellers.

I can certainly recommend PlusNet - they're one of the best ISPs around in my opinion with a great UK-based call-centre staffed by friendly knowledgeable folk.

  Ian in Northampton 13:18 17 Dec 12

Another satisfied PlusNet customer here...

  caccy 14:57 17 Dec 12

Yes they do own Plusnet and also ,I believe, Been with Plusnet quite a few years and would recomend them.Technical service is very good.

  TonyV 18:57 17 Dec 12


In your link there are two Routers being shown, TD.W8960ND and TD.W8961ND which is apparently a newer model and slightly cheaper. Both available from direct. Which is the one you are recommending? I am also with Plusnet, with their router Technicolor TG582n Plusnet, but just thought the Router you suggest may be somewhat quicker.


  Secret-Squirrel 19:11 17 Dec 12

Hi Tony

My link takes you direct to the webpage for the TP-Link TD-W8960N and that's the one I'm recommending. Ignore the link to the newer model as I haven't tried it, and I'm not likely to either as the customer reviews are nowhere near as good as they are for the TD-W8960N.

I can't guarantee that it will improve your connection speeds - but at that price it won't be the end of the world if it doesn't perform as you hoped.

  TonyV 19:44 17 Dec 12


Thanks for that. On top of that, I have to say that I have been with Plusnet for a goodly number of years now, and have to admit that their customer service is extremely good and they are always willing to talk and recommend changes if and when a problem arises. I feel pretty confident that if Newuser939 goes with Plusnet I very much doubt that he will be disappointed! For instance, when I changed to an iMAC from a PC, the Wireless connection was garbage, and Apple recommended I contacted my ISP, Plusnet. This I did and they sent out the new router mentioned in my missive above at no cost, but an extension to my contract with them. This really wasn't a problem for me and accepted it willingly.


  rdave13 23:16 17 Dec 12

I'm also with Plusnet and use the TD-W8960N router. Great bit of kit and cheap at the price. The ISP is also very good.

  Bald Eagle 14:39 18 Dec 12

Is the QSS button on the TP-Link TD-W8960N the same as a WPS button?

  Secret-Squirrel 16:16 18 Dec 12

Yes it is Bald Eagle.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Surface Pro (2017) vs Surface Pro 4

20 groundbreaking 3D animation techniques

How to mine Bitcoin on Mac