I have used Eclipse for over 3 years and have been very happy so far. Good customer service, phone & email plus on site and have been getting on average approx 4Kbps, although at times it has slowed to below 2 but have got nearly 6 at quiet times. On a monthly contract at £14.99. Cannot comment re P2P as I dont use it. I may be biased as am in Exeter, which is where Eclipse is based and started out years ago when I had them on dial up.