PC ADVISOR
FOR MOBILE

The magazine

Poll

When did you get your first home computer?:

View poll results

Have your say in the
PC Advisor forums!

Blogs

Blogs by topic:

'Steve Jobs heart attack' report batters Apple shares

October 7, 2008

Apple's share price took a plunge last week, after rumours that Steve Jobs had suffered a heart attack spread online. And now the US Securities and Exchange Commission is investigating the 'reports' and their effect on Apple's stock, bringing the concept of citizen journalism under fresh scrutiny.

As if stock-market scrutineers and investors didn't have enough to deal with right now, add 'idiot bloggers' and 'gullible fools' to the list.

The Jobs heart attack story first appeared on CNN's blog news site iReport. 'Citizen journalist' Johntw wrote that Jobs had been "rushed to the ER" and had suffered "a major heart attack". iReport published and hung the consequences, as is the nature of a citizen journalist site.

The poster said he had gleaned the news of Jobs' putative heart attack from a hospital insider who was, quote, 'quite reliable'. Quite eh?

Insanely (not so) great

Naturally, the posting was entirely unreliable and insanely popular.

The only genuine threat to Jobs' well-being was the 11 percent crash his Apple shares took upon the 'news' hitting the blogosphere, no doubt almost turning the heart-attack nonsense into a self-fulfilling prophesy.

Myriad other blogs took the story and ran with nary a thought for, you know, facts. Those traditional news outlets that looked for confirmation quickly discovered the story was nonsense. Amateurism may be a glorious English tradition, but there's still room for the hard-bitten pro, it seems.

Any suggestion of instability at the top of an organisation of Apple's size - run by a leader of Jobs' charisma - is bound to hit investor confidence. And so the SEC is going to investigate, to make sure the story wasn't published maliciously with the intention of driving down Apple's stock-market price.

The rise of citizen journalism has been one of the phenomena of the web. No major news story is complete without on-the-scene-images, video and reaction from Johnnies on the spot with a steady hand and a yen for immortality. Not convinced? Think tsunami, terror attack or flood, and the images you've seen are almost certainly derived from Joe Public.

But here's the thing - reaction, footage and colour. Good. Publishing made-up stories? Not so much.

If we all want to be citizen journalists, and the evidence suggests we do, it's probably worthwhile employing at least one cynical old pro to sift the news from the nonsense.

Visit Broadband Advisor for the latest internet news, reviews, tips & tricks

Get the latest news about Apple and Apple products at PC Advisor's dedicated Apple News Spotlight

Posted by: Matt Egan

Submit to: Digg Digg Slashdot delicious Del.icio.us reddit Reddit

What is this?

<<newer entry | older entry>>

Comments

Posted by Striker on October 7, 2008 :

Hope Matt that you are now satisfied with the new class of replies that you are currently attracting.
Just say the word and my team of kindergarten scholars will be back in force to help you raise the bar again.

Posted by Matt Egan on October 7, 2008 :

I don't know anyone by the name of Striker, not sure I've ever come across you or 'your team of kindergarten scholars'. Er, great. But all comments are welcome. (Except those about ducks such as the ones I've just had to delete, naturally!)

Posted by Winterlight on October 12, 2008 :

Could have been a Microsoft executive hiding under the proverbial rock, looking to de-stabilise and rock the Apple boat....Microsoft have no morals....Bill Gates stole the Windows OS from Apple many years ago....enough said!

Posted by Christian on October 16, 2008 :

Happy Birthday matt!!

Posted by oloerourel on November 1, 2008 :

coroelrelri

PC Advisor staff
Blogger Daily news, views and thoughts from the PC Advisor staff as they put together the magazine. Collectively the PC Advisor team has over 100 years of computing experience, so as you'll imagine they're never short of an opinion or two.
Email author(s)

Latest entries

Entries by month

Nov09	\|	Oct09	\|	Sep09	\|	Aug09
Jul09	\|	Jun09	\|	May09	\|	Apr09
Mar09	\|	Feb09	\|	Jan09	\|	Dec08
Nov08	\|	Oct08	\|	Sep08	\|	Aug08
Jul08	\|	Jun08	\|	May08	\|	Apr08
Mar08	\|	Feb08	\|	Jan08	\|	Dec07
Nov07	\|	Oct07	\|	Sep07	\|	Aug07
Jul07	\|	Jun07	\|	May07	\|	Apr07
Mar07	\|	Feb07	\|	Jan07	\|	Dec06
Nov06	\|	Oct06	\|	Sep06	\|	Aug06
Jul06	\|	Jun06	\|	May06	\|	Apr06
Mar06	\|	Feb06	\|	Jan06	\|	Dec05
Nov05	\|	Oct05